Why the Scots die younger: Synthesizing the evidence

G. McCartney, C. Collins, D. Walsh, G. D. Batty

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Objective: To identify explanations for the higher mortality in Scotland relative to other European countries, and to synthesize those best supported by evidence into an overall explanatory framework.

Study design: Review and dialectical synthesis.

Methods: Candidate hypotheses were identified based on a literature review and a series of research dissemination events. Each hypothesis was described and critically evaluated in relation to the Bradford-Hill criteria for causation in observational epidemiology. A synthesis of the more convincing hypotheses was then attempted using a broadly 'dialectical' approach.

Results: Seventeen hypotheses were identified including: artefactual explanations (deprivation, migration); 'downstream explanations' (genetics, health behaviours, individual values); 'midstream' explanations (substance misuse; culture of boundlessness and alienation; family, gender relations and parenting differences; lower social capital; sectarianism; culture of limited social mobility; health service supply or demand; deprivation concentration); and 'upstream' explanations (climate, inequalities, de-industrialization, political attack). There is little evidence available to determine why mortality rates diverged between Scotland and other European countries between 1950 and 1980, but the most plausible explanations at present link to particular industrial, employment, housing and cultural patterns. From 1980 onwards, the higher mortality has been driven by unfavourable health behaviours, and it seems quite likely that these are linked to an intensifying climate of conflict, injustice and disempowerment. This is best explained by developing a synthesis beginning from the political attack hypothesis, which suggests that the neoliberal policies implemented from 1979 onwards across the UK disproportionately affected the Scottish population.

Conclusions: The reasons for the high Scottish mortality between 1950 and 1980 are unclear, but may be linked to particular industrial, employment, housing and cultural patterns. From 1980 onwards, the higher mortality is most likely to be accounted for by a synthesis which begins from the changed political context of the 1980s, and the consequent hopelessness and community disruption experienced. This may have relevance to faltering health improvement in other countries, such as the USA. (C) 2012 The Royal Society for Public Health. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)459-470
Number of pages12
JournalPublic Health
Volume126
Issue number6
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2012

Keywords

  • Scotland
  • Glasgow
  • Mortality
  • Scottish effect
  • Glasgow effect
  • Causality
  • Synthesis

Cite this

McCartney, G. ; Collins, C. ; Walsh, D. ; Batty, G. D. / Why the Scots die younger : Synthesizing the evidence. In: Public Health. 2012 ; Vol. 126, No. 6. pp. 459-470.
@article{79df06d62d094f058a3469b74d3d5a35,
title = "Why the Scots die younger: Synthesizing the evidence",
abstract = "Objective: To identify explanations for the higher mortality in Scotland relative to other European countries, and to synthesize those best supported by evidence into an overall explanatory framework. Study design: Review and dialectical synthesis. Methods: Candidate hypotheses were identified based on a literature review and a series of research dissemination events. Each hypothesis was described and critically evaluated in relation to the Bradford-Hill criteria for causation in observational epidemiology. A synthesis of the more convincing hypotheses was then attempted using a broadly 'dialectical' approach. Results: Seventeen hypotheses were identified including: artefactual explanations (deprivation, migration); 'downstream explanations' (genetics, health behaviours, individual values); 'midstream' explanations (substance misuse; culture of boundlessness and alienation; family, gender relations and parenting differences; lower social capital; sectarianism; culture of limited social mobility; health service supply or demand; deprivation concentration); and 'upstream' explanations (climate, inequalities, de-industrialization, political attack). There is little evidence available to determine why mortality rates diverged between Scotland and other European countries between 1950 and 1980, but the most plausible explanations at present link to particular industrial, employment, housing and cultural patterns. From 1980 onwards, the higher mortality has been driven by unfavourable health behaviours, and it seems quite likely that these are linked to an intensifying climate of conflict, injustice and disempowerment. This is best explained by developing a synthesis beginning from the political attack hypothesis, which suggests that the neoliberal policies implemented from 1979 onwards across the UK disproportionately affected the Scottish population. Conclusions: The reasons for the high Scottish mortality between 1950 and 1980 are unclear, but may be linked to particular industrial, employment, housing and cultural patterns. From 1980 onwards, the higher mortality is most likely to be accounted for by a synthesis which begins from the changed political context of the 1980s, and the consequent hopelessness and community disruption experienced. This may have relevance to faltering health improvement in other countries, such as the USA. (C) 2012 The Royal Society for Public Health. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.",
keywords = "Scotland, Glasgow, Mortality, Scottish effect, Glasgow effect, Causality, Synthesis",
author = "G. McCartney and C. Collins and D. Walsh and Batty, {G. D.}",
year = "2012",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1016/j.puhe.2012.03.007",
language = "English",
volume = "126",
pages = "459--470",
journal = "Public Health",
issn = "0033-3506",
publisher = "Elsevier B.V.",
number = "6",

}

Why the Scots die younger : Synthesizing the evidence. / McCartney, G.; Collins, C.; Walsh, D.; Batty, G. D.

In: Public Health, Vol. 126, No. 6, 06.2012, p. 459-470.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Why the Scots die younger

T2 - Synthesizing the evidence

AU - McCartney, G.

AU - Collins, C.

AU - Walsh, D.

AU - Batty, G. D.

PY - 2012/6

Y1 - 2012/6

N2 - Objective: To identify explanations for the higher mortality in Scotland relative to other European countries, and to synthesize those best supported by evidence into an overall explanatory framework. Study design: Review and dialectical synthesis. Methods: Candidate hypotheses were identified based on a literature review and a series of research dissemination events. Each hypothesis was described and critically evaluated in relation to the Bradford-Hill criteria for causation in observational epidemiology. A synthesis of the more convincing hypotheses was then attempted using a broadly 'dialectical' approach. Results: Seventeen hypotheses were identified including: artefactual explanations (deprivation, migration); 'downstream explanations' (genetics, health behaviours, individual values); 'midstream' explanations (substance misuse; culture of boundlessness and alienation; family, gender relations and parenting differences; lower social capital; sectarianism; culture of limited social mobility; health service supply or demand; deprivation concentration); and 'upstream' explanations (climate, inequalities, de-industrialization, political attack). There is little evidence available to determine why mortality rates diverged between Scotland and other European countries between 1950 and 1980, but the most plausible explanations at present link to particular industrial, employment, housing and cultural patterns. From 1980 onwards, the higher mortality has been driven by unfavourable health behaviours, and it seems quite likely that these are linked to an intensifying climate of conflict, injustice and disempowerment. This is best explained by developing a synthesis beginning from the political attack hypothesis, which suggests that the neoliberal policies implemented from 1979 onwards across the UK disproportionately affected the Scottish population. Conclusions: The reasons for the high Scottish mortality between 1950 and 1980 are unclear, but may be linked to particular industrial, employment, housing and cultural patterns. From 1980 onwards, the higher mortality is most likely to be accounted for by a synthesis which begins from the changed political context of the 1980s, and the consequent hopelessness and community disruption experienced. This may have relevance to faltering health improvement in other countries, such as the USA. (C) 2012 The Royal Society for Public Health. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

AB - Objective: To identify explanations for the higher mortality in Scotland relative to other European countries, and to synthesize those best supported by evidence into an overall explanatory framework. Study design: Review and dialectical synthesis. Methods: Candidate hypotheses were identified based on a literature review and a series of research dissemination events. Each hypothesis was described and critically evaluated in relation to the Bradford-Hill criteria for causation in observational epidemiology. A synthesis of the more convincing hypotheses was then attempted using a broadly 'dialectical' approach. Results: Seventeen hypotheses were identified including: artefactual explanations (deprivation, migration); 'downstream explanations' (genetics, health behaviours, individual values); 'midstream' explanations (substance misuse; culture of boundlessness and alienation; family, gender relations and parenting differences; lower social capital; sectarianism; culture of limited social mobility; health service supply or demand; deprivation concentration); and 'upstream' explanations (climate, inequalities, de-industrialization, political attack). There is little evidence available to determine why mortality rates diverged between Scotland and other European countries between 1950 and 1980, but the most plausible explanations at present link to particular industrial, employment, housing and cultural patterns. From 1980 onwards, the higher mortality has been driven by unfavourable health behaviours, and it seems quite likely that these are linked to an intensifying climate of conflict, injustice and disempowerment. This is best explained by developing a synthesis beginning from the political attack hypothesis, which suggests that the neoliberal policies implemented from 1979 onwards across the UK disproportionately affected the Scottish population. Conclusions: The reasons for the high Scottish mortality between 1950 and 1980 are unclear, but may be linked to particular industrial, employment, housing and cultural patterns. From 1980 onwards, the higher mortality is most likely to be accounted for by a synthesis which begins from the changed political context of the 1980s, and the consequent hopelessness and community disruption experienced. This may have relevance to faltering health improvement in other countries, such as the USA. (C) 2012 The Royal Society for Public Health. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

KW - Scotland

KW - Glasgow

KW - Mortality

KW - Scottish effect

KW - Glasgow effect

KW - Causality

KW - Synthesis

U2 - 10.1016/j.puhe.2012.03.007

DO - 10.1016/j.puhe.2012.03.007

M3 - Article

VL - 126

SP - 459

EP - 470

JO - Public Health

JF - Public Health

SN - 0033-3506

IS - 6

ER -