The Personal Account Books of Sir Walter Scott

Sam McKinstry, Marie Fletcher

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This study examines the personal account books of Sir Walter Scott, the world-renowned Scottish author, a topic not explored before by Scott scholars or accounting historians. It sets the account books in the context of Scott’s accounting education and experience, which took place at the time of the Scottish Enlightenment, an 18th century movement which saw a great flowering of writings on accountancy in Scotland as well as considerable progress in the arts and sciences. The style, layout and content of the account books is also studied from the point of view of elucidating Scott’s domestic financial arrangements and expenditure patterns. These are seen as confirming the insights of Vickery [1998], who posits a liberated role for women such as Mrs Scott in ‘genteel’ households, which Scott’s undoubtedly was. The study also establishes that Scott’s personal expenditures, and indeed his accounting practices, otherwise conformed to the general patriarchal pattern identified by Davidoff and Hall [1987]. The final part of the article uses what has been discovered about Scott’s personal accounting to revisit the question of his financial imprudence (or otherwise) in business. It concludes that Scott’s risk-taking in business was not unreasonable, and was informed by his bookkeeping knowledge and practices.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)59-89
JournalThe Accounting Historians Journal
Volume29
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 2002

Fingerprint

Expenditure
Accounting education
Enlightenment
Accountancy
Accounting practices
Layout
Bookkeeping
18th century
Risk taking
Household
Scotland
Art

Cite this

@article{729eb5e0140141d58ccdee5d26190151,
title = "The Personal Account Books of Sir Walter Scott",
abstract = "This study examines the personal account books of Sir Walter Scott, the world-renowned Scottish author, a topic not explored before by Scott scholars or accounting historians. It sets the account books in the context of Scott’s accounting education and experience, which took place at the time of the Scottish Enlightenment, an 18th century movement which saw a great flowering of writings on accountancy in Scotland as well as considerable progress in the arts and sciences. The style, layout and content of the account books is also studied from the point of view of elucidating Scott’s domestic financial arrangements and expenditure patterns. These are seen as confirming the insights of Vickery [1998], who posits a liberated role for women such as Mrs Scott in ‘genteel’ households, which Scott’s undoubtedly was. The study also establishes that Scott’s personal expenditures, and indeed his accounting practices, otherwise conformed to the general patriarchal pattern identified by Davidoff and Hall [1987]. The final part of the article uses what has been discovered about Scott’s personal accounting to revisit the question of his financial imprudence (or otherwise) in business. It concludes that Scott’s risk-taking in business was not unreasonable, and was informed by his bookkeeping knowledge and practices.",
author = "Sam McKinstry and Marie Fletcher",
year = "2002",
language = "English",
volume = "29",
pages = "59--89",
journal = "The Accounting Historians Journal",
issn = "0148-4184",
publisher = "Academy of Accounting Historians",
number = "2",

}

The Personal Account Books of Sir Walter Scott. / McKinstry, Sam; Fletcher, Marie.

In: The Accounting Historians Journal, Vol. 29, No. 2, 2002, p. 59-89.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - The Personal Account Books of Sir Walter Scott

AU - McKinstry, Sam

AU - Fletcher, Marie

PY - 2002

Y1 - 2002

N2 - This study examines the personal account books of Sir Walter Scott, the world-renowned Scottish author, a topic not explored before by Scott scholars or accounting historians. It sets the account books in the context of Scott’s accounting education and experience, which took place at the time of the Scottish Enlightenment, an 18th century movement which saw a great flowering of writings on accountancy in Scotland as well as considerable progress in the arts and sciences. The style, layout and content of the account books is also studied from the point of view of elucidating Scott’s domestic financial arrangements and expenditure patterns. These are seen as confirming the insights of Vickery [1998], who posits a liberated role for women such as Mrs Scott in ‘genteel’ households, which Scott’s undoubtedly was. The study also establishes that Scott’s personal expenditures, and indeed his accounting practices, otherwise conformed to the general patriarchal pattern identified by Davidoff and Hall [1987]. The final part of the article uses what has been discovered about Scott’s personal accounting to revisit the question of his financial imprudence (or otherwise) in business. It concludes that Scott’s risk-taking in business was not unreasonable, and was informed by his bookkeeping knowledge and practices.

AB - This study examines the personal account books of Sir Walter Scott, the world-renowned Scottish author, a topic not explored before by Scott scholars or accounting historians. It sets the account books in the context of Scott’s accounting education and experience, which took place at the time of the Scottish Enlightenment, an 18th century movement which saw a great flowering of writings on accountancy in Scotland as well as considerable progress in the arts and sciences. The style, layout and content of the account books is also studied from the point of view of elucidating Scott’s domestic financial arrangements and expenditure patterns. These are seen as confirming the insights of Vickery [1998], who posits a liberated role for women such as Mrs Scott in ‘genteel’ households, which Scott’s undoubtedly was. The study also establishes that Scott’s personal expenditures, and indeed his accounting practices, otherwise conformed to the general patriarchal pattern identified by Davidoff and Hall [1987]. The final part of the article uses what has been discovered about Scott’s personal accounting to revisit the question of his financial imprudence (or otherwise) in business. It concludes that Scott’s risk-taking in business was not unreasonable, and was informed by his bookkeeping knowledge and practices.

M3 - Article

VL - 29

SP - 59

EP - 89

JO - The Accounting Historians Journal

JF - The Accounting Historians Journal

SN - 0148-4184

IS - 2

ER -