Searching for excellence in education: knowledge, virtue and presence?

James MacAllister, Gale Macleod, Anne Pirrie

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This article addresses two main questions: (1) what is excellence and (2) should epistemic excellence be the main purpose of education? Though references to excellence have become increasingly frequent in the UK education policy, these questions are perhaps especially important in Scotland where the curriculum is explicitly for excellence. Following Hirst and Peters, it is hypothesised that if the term ‘education’ implies possession of a certain breadth of general knowledge and understanding, then the term ‘excellence’ may imply a deep grasp of a specific body of knowledge. However, after consideration of Dewey's suggestion that being present in the moment is an excellence of childhood, it is concluded that (1) the development of epistemic excellence (having a deep grasp of valuable knowledge) should be regarded as an educational purpose rather than the only educational purpose and (2) pupil engagement with public traditions of knowledge provides necessary but not sufficient conditions for education.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)153-165
Number of pages13
JournalEthics and Education
Volume8
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2013

Fingerprint

education
possession
pupil
childhood
curriculum
Education
Excellence
knowledge
Curriculum
Childhood
Education Policy
Possession
Pupil
Scotland

Cite this

MacAllister, James ; Macleod, Gale ; Pirrie, Anne. / Searching for excellence in education : knowledge, virtue and presence?. In: Ethics and Education. 2013 ; Vol. 8, No. 2. pp. 153-165.
@article{b4ee34cde7664bcf8e6dd2d229ea8401,
title = "Searching for excellence in education: knowledge, virtue and presence?",
abstract = "This article addresses two main questions: (1) what is excellence and (2) should epistemic excellence be the main purpose of education? Though references to excellence have become increasingly frequent in the UK education policy, these questions are perhaps especially important in Scotland where the curriculum is explicitly for excellence. Following Hirst and Peters, it is hypothesised that if the term ‘education’ implies possession of a certain breadth of general knowledge and understanding, then the term ‘excellence’ may imply a deep grasp of a specific body of knowledge. However, after consideration of Dewey's suggestion that being present in the moment is an excellence of childhood, it is concluded that (1) the development of epistemic excellence (having a deep grasp of valuable knowledge) should be regarded as an educational purpose rather than the only educational purpose and (2) pupil engagement with public traditions of knowledge provides necessary but not sufficient conditions for education.",
author = "James MacAllister and Gale Macleod and Anne Pirrie",
year = "2013",
doi = "10.1080/17449642.2013.843964",
language = "English",
volume = "8",
pages = "153--165",
journal = "Ethics and Education",
issn = "1744-9642",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",
number = "2",

}

Searching for excellence in education : knowledge, virtue and presence? / MacAllister, James; Macleod, Gale; Pirrie, Anne.

In: Ethics and Education, Vol. 8, No. 2, 2013, p. 153-165.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Searching for excellence in education

T2 - knowledge, virtue and presence?

AU - MacAllister, James

AU - Macleod, Gale

AU - Pirrie, Anne

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - This article addresses two main questions: (1) what is excellence and (2) should epistemic excellence be the main purpose of education? Though references to excellence have become increasingly frequent in the UK education policy, these questions are perhaps especially important in Scotland where the curriculum is explicitly for excellence. Following Hirst and Peters, it is hypothesised that if the term ‘education’ implies possession of a certain breadth of general knowledge and understanding, then the term ‘excellence’ may imply a deep grasp of a specific body of knowledge. However, after consideration of Dewey's suggestion that being present in the moment is an excellence of childhood, it is concluded that (1) the development of epistemic excellence (having a deep grasp of valuable knowledge) should be regarded as an educational purpose rather than the only educational purpose and (2) pupil engagement with public traditions of knowledge provides necessary but not sufficient conditions for education.

AB - This article addresses two main questions: (1) what is excellence and (2) should epistemic excellence be the main purpose of education? Though references to excellence have become increasingly frequent in the UK education policy, these questions are perhaps especially important in Scotland where the curriculum is explicitly for excellence. Following Hirst and Peters, it is hypothesised that if the term ‘education’ implies possession of a certain breadth of general knowledge and understanding, then the term ‘excellence’ may imply a deep grasp of a specific body of knowledge. However, after consideration of Dewey's suggestion that being present in the moment is an excellence of childhood, it is concluded that (1) the development of epistemic excellence (having a deep grasp of valuable knowledge) should be regarded as an educational purpose rather than the only educational purpose and (2) pupil engagement with public traditions of knowledge provides necessary but not sufficient conditions for education.

U2 - 10.1080/17449642.2013.843964

DO - 10.1080/17449642.2013.843964

M3 - Article

VL - 8

SP - 153

EP - 165

JO - Ethics and Education

JF - Ethics and Education

SN - 1744-9642

IS - 2

ER -