Role requirements in academic recruitment for construction & engineering

Nick Pilcher*, Laurent Galbrun, Nigel Craig, Mike Murray, Alan M. Forster, Stuart Tennant

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Two ongoing and recurrent debates in the employment of academic staff are (1) how much industry experience should faculty staff have? and (2) what priority is given to research, teaching or both? Such debates take place worldwide and are particularly relevant to vocational subject areas. Through a statistical analysis of circa 200 job adverts for lecturer / assistant professor, senior lecturer / associate professor, and professor / full professor positions in Construction and Engineering posts in the UK, this paper investigates the essential and desirable attributes required for ‘research’, ‘teaching’ and ‘overall requirements’. Analysis shows institutions unmistakably focus on, and coherently recruit for research, but demonstrate very little reasoned approach to recruiting for teaching. Indeed, findings identify ‘administration’ as the key teaching priority. Further empirical analysis demonstrates no significant difference in recruitment strategy before and after the introduction of the Teaching Excellence Framework, despite its aim to put teaching excellence to the fore.
Original languageEnglish
JournalEuropean Journal of Engineering Education
Early online date12 Feb 2020
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 12 Feb 2020

Fingerprint

Teaching
university teacher
engineering
teaching research
staff
assistant
statistical analysis
Statistical methods
industry
Industry
experience

Keywords

  • Construction and engineering
  • Recruitment
  • Research
  • Teaching
  • Employment attributes

Cite this

Pilcher, Nick ; Galbrun, Laurent ; Craig, Nigel ; Murray, Mike ; Forster, Alan M. ; Tennant, Stuart. / Role requirements in academic recruitment for construction & engineering. In: European Journal of Engineering Education. 2020.
@article{a4665ec76ca74aad9213df3832fb7dd4,
title = "Role requirements in academic recruitment for construction & engineering",
abstract = "Two ongoing and recurrent debates in the employment of academic staff are (1) how much industry experience should faculty staff have? and (2) what priority is given to research, teaching or both? Such debates take place worldwide and are particularly relevant to vocational subject areas. Through a statistical analysis of circa 200 job adverts for lecturer / assistant professor, senior lecturer / associate professor, and professor / full professor positions in Construction and Engineering posts in the UK, this paper investigates the essential and desirable attributes required for ‘research’, ‘teaching’ and ‘overall requirements’. Analysis shows institutions unmistakably focus on, and coherently recruit for research, but demonstrate very little reasoned approach to recruiting for teaching. Indeed, findings identify ‘administration’ as the key teaching priority. Further empirical analysis demonstrates no significant difference in recruitment strategy before and after the introduction of the Teaching Excellence Framework, despite its aim to put teaching excellence to the fore.",
keywords = "Construction and engineering, Recruitment, Research, Teaching, Employment attributes",
author = "Nick Pilcher and Laurent Galbrun and Nigel Craig and Mike Murray and Forster, {Alan M.} and Stuart Tennant",
year = "2020",
month = "2",
day = "12",
doi = "10.1080/03043797.2020.1725451",
language = "English",
journal = "European Journal of Engineering Education",
issn = "0304-3797",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",

}

Role requirements in academic recruitment for construction & engineering. / Pilcher, Nick; Galbrun, Laurent; Craig, Nigel; Murray, Mike; Forster, Alan M.; Tennant, Stuart.

In: European Journal of Engineering Education, 12.02.2020.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Role requirements in academic recruitment for construction & engineering

AU - Pilcher, Nick

AU - Galbrun, Laurent

AU - Craig, Nigel

AU - Murray, Mike

AU - Forster, Alan M.

AU - Tennant, Stuart

PY - 2020/2/12

Y1 - 2020/2/12

N2 - Two ongoing and recurrent debates in the employment of academic staff are (1) how much industry experience should faculty staff have? and (2) what priority is given to research, teaching or both? Such debates take place worldwide and are particularly relevant to vocational subject areas. Through a statistical analysis of circa 200 job adverts for lecturer / assistant professor, senior lecturer / associate professor, and professor / full professor positions in Construction and Engineering posts in the UK, this paper investigates the essential and desirable attributes required for ‘research’, ‘teaching’ and ‘overall requirements’. Analysis shows institutions unmistakably focus on, and coherently recruit for research, but demonstrate very little reasoned approach to recruiting for teaching. Indeed, findings identify ‘administration’ as the key teaching priority. Further empirical analysis demonstrates no significant difference in recruitment strategy before and after the introduction of the Teaching Excellence Framework, despite its aim to put teaching excellence to the fore.

AB - Two ongoing and recurrent debates in the employment of academic staff are (1) how much industry experience should faculty staff have? and (2) what priority is given to research, teaching or both? Such debates take place worldwide and are particularly relevant to vocational subject areas. Through a statistical analysis of circa 200 job adverts for lecturer / assistant professor, senior lecturer / associate professor, and professor / full professor positions in Construction and Engineering posts in the UK, this paper investigates the essential and desirable attributes required for ‘research’, ‘teaching’ and ‘overall requirements’. Analysis shows institutions unmistakably focus on, and coherently recruit for research, but demonstrate very little reasoned approach to recruiting for teaching. Indeed, findings identify ‘administration’ as the key teaching priority. Further empirical analysis demonstrates no significant difference in recruitment strategy before and after the introduction of the Teaching Excellence Framework, despite its aim to put teaching excellence to the fore.

KW - Construction and engineering

KW - Recruitment

KW - Research

KW - Teaching

KW - Employment attributes

U2 - 10.1080/03043797.2020.1725451

DO - 10.1080/03043797.2020.1725451

M3 - Article

JO - European Journal of Engineering Education

JF - European Journal of Engineering Education

SN - 0304-3797

ER -