Research in UK universities: a tale of two subjects – economics and econometrics; and business and management studies

James Johnston, Alan Reeves

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This paper explores the comparative performance of two subject areas (Units of Assessment – UOAs) in the UK national Research Assessment Exercises of 1992, 1996, 2001, 2008 and the Research Excellence Framework of 2014. The Units of Assessment are Economics and Econometrics; and Business and Management Studies. Given the wide range of disciplines in the Business and Management Studies UOA universities have the choice of submitting their economics and econometrics research either to it or to the Economics and Econometrics UOA. Over the period 1992–2014 the number of universities entering the Economics and Econometrics UOA declined significantly in contrast to the growth in the number entering the Business and Management Studies UOA. The reasons for this include the finding that university managers were more likely to tolerate poor performance (measured by internal and external gaps) in Business and Management Studies than in Economics and Econometrics. Considerable differences were found between old (pre-1992) and new (post-1992) universities, with Economics and Econometrics now solely the domain of old universities as new ones have withdrawn. In sharp contrast, Business and Management Studies has a good balance of old and new universities.
Original languageEnglish
JournalEuropean Journal of Higher Education
Early online date28 Mar 2019
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 28 Mar 2019

Fingerprint

Econometrics
Business and management studies
Economics
Excellence
Managers
Research assessment exercise

Keywords

  • Research evaluation
  • RAE/REF
  • gaps
  • stratification
  • UK universities
  • decision-making

Cite this

@article{64228267040a4a37af59ba60c95c9762,
title = "Research in UK universities: a tale of two subjects – economics and econometrics; and business and management studies",
abstract = "This paper explores the comparative performance of two subject areas (Units of Assessment – UOAs) in the UK national Research Assessment Exercises of 1992, 1996, 2001, 2008 and the Research Excellence Framework of 2014. The Units of Assessment are Economics and Econometrics; and Business and Management Studies. Given the wide range of disciplines in the Business and Management Studies UOA universities have the choice of submitting their economics and econometrics research either to it or to the Economics and Econometrics UOA. Over the period 1992–2014 the number of universities entering the Economics and Econometrics UOA declined significantly in contrast to the growth in the number entering the Business and Management Studies UOA. The reasons for this include the finding that university managers were more likely to tolerate poor performance (measured by internal and external gaps) in Business and Management Studies than in Economics and Econometrics. Considerable differences were found between old (pre-1992) and new (post-1992) universities, with Economics and Econometrics now solely the domain of old universities as new ones have withdrawn. In sharp contrast, Business and Management Studies has a good balance of old and new universities.",
keywords = "Research evaluation, RAE/REF, gaps, stratification, UK universities, decision-making",
author = "James Johnston and Alan Reeves",
year = "2019",
month = "3",
day = "28",
doi = "10.1080/21568235.2019.1597747",
language = "English",
journal = "European Journal of Higher Education",
issn = "2156-8235",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Research in UK universities

T2 - a tale of two subjects – economics and econometrics; and business and management studies

AU - Johnston, James

AU - Reeves, Alan

PY - 2019/3/28

Y1 - 2019/3/28

N2 - This paper explores the comparative performance of two subject areas (Units of Assessment – UOAs) in the UK national Research Assessment Exercises of 1992, 1996, 2001, 2008 and the Research Excellence Framework of 2014. The Units of Assessment are Economics and Econometrics; and Business and Management Studies. Given the wide range of disciplines in the Business and Management Studies UOA universities have the choice of submitting their economics and econometrics research either to it or to the Economics and Econometrics UOA. Over the period 1992–2014 the number of universities entering the Economics and Econometrics UOA declined significantly in contrast to the growth in the number entering the Business and Management Studies UOA. The reasons for this include the finding that university managers were more likely to tolerate poor performance (measured by internal and external gaps) in Business and Management Studies than in Economics and Econometrics. Considerable differences were found between old (pre-1992) and new (post-1992) universities, with Economics and Econometrics now solely the domain of old universities as new ones have withdrawn. In sharp contrast, Business and Management Studies has a good balance of old and new universities.

AB - This paper explores the comparative performance of two subject areas (Units of Assessment – UOAs) in the UK national Research Assessment Exercises of 1992, 1996, 2001, 2008 and the Research Excellence Framework of 2014. The Units of Assessment are Economics and Econometrics; and Business and Management Studies. Given the wide range of disciplines in the Business and Management Studies UOA universities have the choice of submitting their economics and econometrics research either to it or to the Economics and Econometrics UOA. Over the period 1992–2014 the number of universities entering the Economics and Econometrics UOA declined significantly in contrast to the growth in the number entering the Business and Management Studies UOA. The reasons for this include the finding that university managers were more likely to tolerate poor performance (measured by internal and external gaps) in Business and Management Studies than in Economics and Econometrics. Considerable differences were found between old (pre-1992) and new (post-1992) universities, with Economics and Econometrics now solely the domain of old universities as new ones have withdrawn. In sharp contrast, Business and Management Studies has a good balance of old and new universities.

KW - Research evaluation

KW - RAE/REF

KW - gaps

KW - stratification

KW - UK universities

KW - decision-making

U2 - 10.1080/21568235.2019.1597747

DO - 10.1080/21568235.2019.1597747

M3 - Article

JO - European Journal of Higher Education

JF - European Journal of Higher Education

SN - 2156-8235

ER -