Reflective practice and student satisfaction: never the twain shall meet?

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

11 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

The focus of this article is the inter-relationship between two canonical notions in contemporary education discourse: ‘reflective practice’ and ‘student satisfaction’ in the context of the marketisation of higher education across Europe and the concomitant emphasis on student autonomy and institutional competitiveness. Drawing on the work of Jan Masschelein and Tim Ingold, the authors offer a critique of contemporary attempts to reanimate the notion of reflective practice. Drawing upon the work of Sharon Todd, the authors explore the theoretical underpinnings of contemporary approaches to reflective practice and suggest that these betoken an implicit commitment to a vision of education as a process of transmission rather than of educating the gaze. They trace the aetiology of the former back to the direction of education policy in the decades since the adoption of the Lisbon Strategy. They conclude that a nuanced approach to reflective practice entails a consideration of student satisfaction and fundamental shift in emphasis from epistemological or methodological towards existential concerns.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)483-496
Number of pages14
JournalEuropean Educational Research Journal
Volume18
Issue number4
Early online date24 Oct 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 31 Jul 2019

Fingerprint

education
student
etiology
competitiveness
autonomy
commitment
discourse

Keywords

  • Arendt on thinking and judgement
  • Neoliberalism in Higher Education
  • Poor pedagogy
  • Reflective practice
  • Student satisfaction

Cite this

@article{684c7e7e427b4818a54116a2636a5992,
title = "Reflective practice and student satisfaction: never the twain shall meet?",
abstract = "The focus of this article is the inter-relationship between two canonical notions in contemporary education discourse: ‘reflective practice’ and ‘student satisfaction’ in the context of the marketisation of higher education across Europe and the concomitant emphasis on student autonomy and institutional competitiveness. Drawing on the work of Jan Masschelein and Tim Ingold, the authors offer a critique of contemporary attempts to reanimate the notion of reflective practice. Drawing upon the work of Sharon Todd, the authors explore the theoretical underpinnings of contemporary approaches to reflective practice and suggest that these betoken an implicit commitment to a vision of education as a process of transmission rather than of educating the gaze. They trace the aetiology of the former back to the direction of education policy in the decades since the adoption of the Lisbon Strategy. They conclude that a nuanced approach to reflective practice entails a consideration of student satisfaction and fundamental shift in emphasis from epistemological or methodological towards existential concerns.",
keywords = "Arendt on thinking and judgement, Neoliberalism in Higher Education, Poor pedagogy, Reflective practice, Student satisfaction",
author = "Anne Pirrie and Stephen Day",
year = "2019",
month = "7",
day = "31",
doi = "10.1177/1474904118804423",
language = "English",
volume = "18",
pages = "483--496",
journal = "European Educational Research Journal",
issn = "1474-9041",
publisher = "SAGE Publications",
number = "4",

}

Reflective practice and student satisfaction : never the twain shall meet? / Pirrie, Anne; Day, Stephen.

In: European Educational Research Journal, Vol. 18, No. 4, 31.07.2019, p. 483-496.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Reflective practice and student satisfaction

T2 - never the twain shall meet?

AU - Pirrie, Anne

AU - Day, Stephen

PY - 2019/7/31

Y1 - 2019/7/31

N2 - The focus of this article is the inter-relationship between two canonical notions in contemporary education discourse: ‘reflective practice’ and ‘student satisfaction’ in the context of the marketisation of higher education across Europe and the concomitant emphasis on student autonomy and institutional competitiveness. Drawing on the work of Jan Masschelein and Tim Ingold, the authors offer a critique of contemporary attempts to reanimate the notion of reflective practice. Drawing upon the work of Sharon Todd, the authors explore the theoretical underpinnings of contemporary approaches to reflective practice and suggest that these betoken an implicit commitment to a vision of education as a process of transmission rather than of educating the gaze. They trace the aetiology of the former back to the direction of education policy in the decades since the adoption of the Lisbon Strategy. They conclude that a nuanced approach to reflective practice entails a consideration of student satisfaction and fundamental shift in emphasis from epistemological or methodological towards existential concerns.

AB - The focus of this article is the inter-relationship between two canonical notions in contemporary education discourse: ‘reflective practice’ and ‘student satisfaction’ in the context of the marketisation of higher education across Europe and the concomitant emphasis on student autonomy and institutional competitiveness. Drawing on the work of Jan Masschelein and Tim Ingold, the authors offer a critique of contemporary attempts to reanimate the notion of reflective practice. Drawing upon the work of Sharon Todd, the authors explore the theoretical underpinnings of contemporary approaches to reflective practice and suggest that these betoken an implicit commitment to a vision of education as a process of transmission rather than of educating the gaze. They trace the aetiology of the former back to the direction of education policy in the decades since the adoption of the Lisbon Strategy. They conclude that a nuanced approach to reflective practice entails a consideration of student satisfaction and fundamental shift in emphasis from epistemological or methodological towards existential concerns.

KW - Arendt on thinking and judgement

KW - Neoliberalism in Higher Education

KW - Poor pedagogy

KW - Reflective practice

KW - Student satisfaction

U2 - 10.1177/1474904118804423

DO - 10.1177/1474904118804423

M3 - Article

VL - 18

SP - 483

EP - 496

JO - European Educational Research Journal

JF - European Educational Research Journal

SN - 1474-9041

IS - 4

ER -