Quantifying vertical stress transmission and compaction-induced soil structure using sensor mat and X-ray computed tomography

Muhammad Naveed, Per Schjønning, Thomas Keller, Lis W. de Jonge, Per Moldrup, Mathieu Lamandé

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Accurate estimation of stress transmission in soil and quantification of compaction-induced soil pore structure is important for efficient soil use and management. Continuum mechanics have so far mostly been applied for agricultural soils, even if topsoil structure is aggregated due to regular tillage. In this study, partially confined uniaxial compression tests were carried out on intact topsoil columns placed on subsoil columns. Two methods were employed for estimation of stress transmission in soil: (i) soil deformation patterns were quantified using X-ray CT and converted to stress distributions, and (ii) a tactile sensor mat was employed for measuring stresses at the interface of the topsoil and subsoil columns. The resulting soil pore structure under applied stresses was quantified using X-ray CT and by air-permeability measurements. In topsoil discrete stress transmission patterns were observed at 275 kPa applied stress, whereas continuum-like stress transmission was observed at 620 kPa. At the interface of topsoil and subsoil, discrete stress transmission patterns were observed at all applied stresses ranging from 68 to 620 kPa, but it was less discrete as we moved from lower to higher applied stresses. Our results imply that at lower stresses the stress transmission in arable soil was discrete because the applied load was mainly transmitted through chain of aggregates. At higher applied stresses the soil/aggregates deformed and to a larger degree resembled a continuous material where continuum-like stress transmission patterns were observed. We found that continuum stress transmission patterns were well simulated with models based on the elasticity theory (e.g., Boussinesq, 1885) compared to discrete stress transmission patterns. The soil pore structure was affected by increasing applied stresses. Total porosity was reduced 5–16% and macroporosity (pores > 0.5 mm) 50–85% at 620 kPa for topsoils. For subsoils – serving here as the material underlying the topsoil tests columns – only a small decrease was observed in both total porosity and macroporosity. Air permeability was reduced 55–80% for topsoils and 10–20% for subsoils at 620 kPa stress.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)110-122
JournalSoil & Tillage Research
Volume158
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - May 2016
Externally publishedYes

Keywords

  • Soil compaction
  • Stress transmission
  • Soil deformation
  • Soil structure

Cite this

Naveed, Muhammad ; Schjønning, Per ; Keller, Thomas ; de Jonge, Lis W. ; Moldrup, Per ; Lamandé, Mathieu. / Quantifying vertical stress transmission and compaction-induced soil structure using sensor mat and X-ray computed tomography. In: Soil & Tillage Research. 2016 ; Vol. 158. pp. 110-122.
@article{49d4581a464c48ebbf89a8e852329064,
title = "Quantifying vertical stress transmission and compaction-induced soil structure using sensor mat and X-ray computed tomography",
abstract = "Accurate estimation of stress transmission in soil and quantification of compaction-induced soil pore structure is important for efficient soil use and management. Continuum mechanics have so far mostly been applied for agricultural soils, even if topsoil structure is aggregated due to regular tillage. In this study, partially confined uniaxial compression tests were carried out on intact topsoil columns placed on subsoil columns. Two methods were employed for estimation of stress transmission in soil: (i) soil deformation patterns were quantified using X-ray CT and converted to stress distributions, and (ii) a tactile sensor mat was employed for measuring stresses at the interface of the topsoil and subsoil columns. The resulting soil pore structure under applied stresses was quantified using X-ray CT and by air-permeability measurements. In topsoil discrete stress transmission patterns were observed at 275 kPa applied stress, whereas continuum-like stress transmission was observed at 620 kPa. At the interface of topsoil and subsoil, discrete stress transmission patterns were observed at all applied stresses ranging from 68 to 620 kPa, but it was less discrete as we moved from lower to higher applied stresses. Our results imply that at lower stresses the stress transmission in arable soil was discrete because the applied load was mainly transmitted through chain of aggregates. At higher applied stresses the soil/aggregates deformed and to a larger degree resembled a continuous material where continuum-like stress transmission patterns were observed. We found that continuum stress transmission patterns were well simulated with models based on the elasticity theory (e.g., Boussinesq, 1885) compared to discrete stress transmission patterns. The soil pore structure was affected by increasing applied stresses. Total porosity was reduced 5–16{\%} and macroporosity (pores > 0.5 mm) 50–85{\%} at 620 kPa for topsoils. For subsoils – serving here as the material underlying the topsoil tests columns – only a small decrease was observed in both total porosity and macroporosity. Air permeability was reduced 55–80{\%} for topsoils and 10–20{\%} for subsoils at 620 kPa stress.",
keywords = "Soil compaction, Stress transmission, Soil deformation, Soil structure",
author = "Muhammad Naveed and Per Schj{\o}nning and Thomas Keller and {de Jonge}, {Lis W.} and Per Moldrup and Mathieu Lamand{\'e}",
year = "2016",
month = "5",
doi = "10.1016/j.still.2015.12.006",
language = "English",
volume = "158",
pages = "110--122",
journal = "Soil & Tillage Research",
issn = "0167-1987",
publisher = "Elsevier B.V.",

}

Quantifying vertical stress transmission and compaction-induced soil structure using sensor mat and X-ray computed tomography. / Naveed, Muhammad; Schjønning, Per; Keller, Thomas; de Jonge, Lis W.; Moldrup, Per; Lamandé, Mathieu.

In: Soil & Tillage Research, Vol. 158, 05.2016, p. 110-122.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Quantifying vertical stress transmission and compaction-induced soil structure using sensor mat and X-ray computed tomography

AU - Naveed, Muhammad

AU - Schjønning, Per

AU - Keller, Thomas

AU - de Jonge, Lis W.

AU - Moldrup, Per

AU - Lamandé, Mathieu

PY - 2016/5

Y1 - 2016/5

N2 - Accurate estimation of stress transmission in soil and quantification of compaction-induced soil pore structure is important for efficient soil use and management. Continuum mechanics have so far mostly been applied for agricultural soils, even if topsoil structure is aggregated due to regular tillage. In this study, partially confined uniaxial compression tests were carried out on intact topsoil columns placed on subsoil columns. Two methods were employed for estimation of stress transmission in soil: (i) soil deformation patterns were quantified using X-ray CT and converted to stress distributions, and (ii) a tactile sensor mat was employed for measuring stresses at the interface of the topsoil and subsoil columns. The resulting soil pore structure under applied stresses was quantified using X-ray CT and by air-permeability measurements. In topsoil discrete stress transmission patterns were observed at 275 kPa applied stress, whereas continuum-like stress transmission was observed at 620 kPa. At the interface of topsoil and subsoil, discrete stress transmission patterns were observed at all applied stresses ranging from 68 to 620 kPa, but it was less discrete as we moved from lower to higher applied stresses. Our results imply that at lower stresses the stress transmission in arable soil was discrete because the applied load was mainly transmitted through chain of aggregates. At higher applied stresses the soil/aggregates deformed and to a larger degree resembled a continuous material where continuum-like stress transmission patterns were observed. We found that continuum stress transmission patterns were well simulated with models based on the elasticity theory (e.g., Boussinesq, 1885) compared to discrete stress transmission patterns. The soil pore structure was affected by increasing applied stresses. Total porosity was reduced 5–16% and macroporosity (pores > 0.5 mm) 50–85% at 620 kPa for topsoils. For subsoils – serving here as the material underlying the topsoil tests columns – only a small decrease was observed in both total porosity and macroporosity. Air permeability was reduced 55–80% for topsoils and 10–20% for subsoils at 620 kPa stress.

AB - Accurate estimation of stress transmission in soil and quantification of compaction-induced soil pore structure is important for efficient soil use and management. Continuum mechanics have so far mostly been applied for agricultural soils, even if topsoil structure is aggregated due to regular tillage. In this study, partially confined uniaxial compression tests were carried out on intact topsoil columns placed on subsoil columns. Two methods were employed for estimation of stress transmission in soil: (i) soil deformation patterns were quantified using X-ray CT and converted to stress distributions, and (ii) a tactile sensor mat was employed for measuring stresses at the interface of the topsoil and subsoil columns. The resulting soil pore structure under applied stresses was quantified using X-ray CT and by air-permeability measurements. In topsoil discrete stress transmission patterns were observed at 275 kPa applied stress, whereas continuum-like stress transmission was observed at 620 kPa. At the interface of topsoil and subsoil, discrete stress transmission patterns were observed at all applied stresses ranging from 68 to 620 kPa, but it was less discrete as we moved from lower to higher applied stresses. Our results imply that at lower stresses the stress transmission in arable soil was discrete because the applied load was mainly transmitted through chain of aggregates. At higher applied stresses the soil/aggregates deformed and to a larger degree resembled a continuous material where continuum-like stress transmission patterns were observed. We found that continuum stress transmission patterns were well simulated with models based on the elasticity theory (e.g., Boussinesq, 1885) compared to discrete stress transmission patterns. The soil pore structure was affected by increasing applied stresses. Total porosity was reduced 5–16% and macroporosity (pores > 0.5 mm) 50–85% at 620 kPa for topsoils. For subsoils – serving here as the material underlying the topsoil tests columns – only a small decrease was observed in both total porosity and macroporosity. Air permeability was reduced 55–80% for topsoils and 10–20% for subsoils at 620 kPa stress.

KW - Soil compaction

KW - Stress transmission

KW - Soil deformation

KW - Soil structure

U2 - 10.1016/j.still.2015.12.006

DO - 10.1016/j.still.2015.12.006

M3 - Article

VL - 158

SP - 110

EP - 122

JO - Soil & Tillage Research

JF - Soil & Tillage Research

SN - 0167-1987

ER -