Predator cue studies reveal strong trait-mediated effects in communities despite variation in experimental designs

Rachel A. Paterson, Daniel W. Pritchard, Jaimie T. A. Dick, Mhairi E. Alexander, Melanie J. Hatcher, Alison M. Dunn

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Nonconsumptive or trait-mediated effects of predators on their prey often outweigh density-mediated interactions where predators consume prey. For instance, predator presence can alter prey behaviour, physiology, morphology and/or development. Despite a burgeoning literature, our ability to identify general patterns in prey behavioural responses may be influenced by the inconsistent methodologies of predator cue experiments used to assess trait-mediated effects. We therefore conducted a meta-analysis to highlight variables (e.g. water type, predator husbandry, exposure time) that may influence invertebrate prey's behavioural responses to fish predator cues. This revealed that changes in prey activity and refuge use were remarkably consistent overall, despite wide differences in experimental methodologies. Our meta-analysis shows that invertebrates altered their behaviour to predator cues of both fish that were fed the focal invertebrate and those that were fed other prey types, which suggests that invertebrates were not responding to specific diet information in the fish cues. Invertebrates also altered their behaviour regardless of predator cue addition regimes and fish satiation levels. Cue intensity and exposure time did not have significant effects on invertebrate behaviour. We also highlight that potentially confounding factors, such as parasitism, were rarely recorded in sufficient detail to assess the magnitude of their effects. By examining the likelihood of detecting trait-mediated effects under large variations in experimental design, our study demonstrates that trait-mediated effects are likely to have pervasive and powerful influences in nature.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1301-1313
JournalAnimal Behaviour
Volume86
Issue number6
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2013
Externally publishedYes

Keywords

  • indirect effect
  • nonconsumptive effect
  • predator avoidance
  • predator cue
  • trait-mediated effect

Cite this

Paterson, Rachel A. ; Pritchard, Daniel W. ; Dick, Jaimie T. A. ; Alexander, Mhairi E. ; Hatcher, Melanie J. ; Dunn, Alison M. / Predator cue studies reveal strong trait-mediated effects in communities despite variation in experimental designs. In: Animal Behaviour. 2013 ; Vol. 86, No. 6. pp. 1301-1313.
@article{6dbf9365ba3443b282eeacc7345c1ca8,
title = "Predator cue studies reveal strong trait-mediated effects in communities despite variation in experimental designs",
abstract = "Nonconsumptive or trait-mediated effects of predators on their prey often outweigh density-mediated interactions where predators consume prey. For instance, predator presence can alter prey behaviour, physiology, morphology and/or development. Despite a burgeoning literature, our ability to identify general patterns in prey behavioural responses may be influenced by the inconsistent methodologies of predator cue experiments used to assess trait-mediated effects. We therefore conducted a meta-analysis to highlight variables (e.g. water type, predator husbandry, exposure time) that may influence invertebrate prey's behavioural responses to fish predator cues. This revealed that changes in prey activity and refuge use were remarkably consistent overall, despite wide differences in experimental methodologies. Our meta-analysis shows that invertebrates altered their behaviour to predator cues of both fish that were fed the focal invertebrate and those that were fed other prey types, which suggests that invertebrates were not responding to specific diet information in the fish cues. Invertebrates also altered their behaviour regardless of predator cue addition regimes and fish satiation levels. Cue intensity and exposure time did not have significant effects on invertebrate behaviour. We also highlight that potentially confounding factors, such as parasitism, were rarely recorded in sufficient detail to assess the magnitude of their effects. By examining the likelihood of detecting trait-mediated effects under large variations in experimental design, our study demonstrates that trait-mediated effects are likely to have pervasive and powerful influences in nature.",
keywords = "indirect effect, nonconsumptive effect, predator avoidance, predator cue, trait-mediated effect",
author = "Paterson, {Rachel A.} and Pritchard, {Daniel W.} and Dick, {Jaimie T. A.} and Alexander, {Mhairi E.} and Hatcher, {Melanie J.} and Dunn, {Alison M.}",
year = "2013",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1016/j.anbehav.2013.09.036",
language = "English",
volume = "86",
pages = "1301--1313",
journal = "Animal Behaviour",
issn = "0003-3472",
publisher = "Elsevier B.V.",
number = "6",

}

Predator cue studies reveal strong trait-mediated effects in communities despite variation in experimental designs. / Paterson, Rachel A.; Pritchard, Daniel W.; Dick, Jaimie T. A.; Alexander, Mhairi E.; Hatcher, Melanie J.; Dunn, Alison M.

In: Animal Behaviour, Vol. 86, No. 6, 12.2013, p. 1301-1313.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Predator cue studies reveal strong trait-mediated effects in communities despite variation in experimental designs

AU - Paterson, Rachel A.

AU - Pritchard, Daniel W.

AU - Dick, Jaimie T. A.

AU - Alexander, Mhairi E.

AU - Hatcher, Melanie J.

AU - Dunn, Alison M.

PY - 2013/12

Y1 - 2013/12

N2 - Nonconsumptive or trait-mediated effects of predators on their prey often outweigh density-mediated interactions where predators consume prey. For instance, predator presence can alter prey behaviour, physiology, morphology and/or development. Despite a burgeoning literature, our ability to identify general patterns in prey behavioural responses may be influenced by the inconsistent methodologies of predator cue experiments used to assess trait-mediated effects. We therefore conducted a meta-analysis to highlight variables (e.g. water type, predator husbandry, exposure time) that may influence invertebrate prey's behavioural responses to fish predator cues. This revealed that changes in prey activity and refuge use were remarkably consistent overall, despite wide differences in experimental methodologies. Our meta-analysis shows that invertebrates altered their behaviour to predator cues of both fish that were fed the focal invertebrate and those that were fed other prey types, which suggests that invertebrates were not responding to specific diet information in the fish cues. Invertebrates also altered their behaviour regardless of predator cue addition regimes and fish satiation levels. Cue intensity and exposure time did not have significant effects on invertebrate behaviour. We also highlight that potentially confounding factors, such as parasitism, were rarely recorded in sufficient detail to assess the magnitude of their effects. By examining the likelihood of detecting trait-mediated effects under large variations in experimental design, our study demonstrates that trait-mediated effects are likely to have pervasive and powerful influences in nature.

AB - Nonconsumptive or trait-mediated effects of predators on their prey often outweigh density-mediated interactions where predators consume prey. For instance, predator presence can alter prey behaviour, physiology, morphology and/or development. Despite a burgeoning literature, our ability to identify general patterns in prey behavioural responses may be influenced by the inconsistent methodologies of predator cue experiments used to assess trait-mediated effects. We therefore conducted a meta-analysis to highlight variables (e.g. water type, predator husbandry, exposure time) that may influence invertebrate prey's behavioural responses to fish predator cues. This revealed that changes in prey activity and refuge use were remarkably consistent overall, despite wide differences in experimental methodologies. Our meta-analysis shows that invertebrates altered their behaviour to predator cues of both fish that were fed the focal invertebrate and those that were fed other prey types, which suggests that invertebrates were not responding to specific diet information in the fish cues. Invertebrates also altered their behaviour regardless of predator cue addition regimes and fish satiation levels. Cue intensity and exposure time did not have significant effects on invertebrate behaviour. We also highlight that potentially confounding factors, such as parasitism, were rarely recorded in sufficient detail to assess the magnitude of their effects. By examining the likelihood of detecting trait-mediated effects under large variations in experimental design, our study demonstrates that trait-mediated effects are likely to have pervasive and powerful influences in nature.

KW - indirect effect

KW - nonconsumptive effect

KW - predator avoidance

KW - predator cue

KW - trait-mediated effect

U2 - 10.1016/j.anbehav.2013.09.036

DO - 10.1016/j.anbehav.2013.09.036

M3 - Article

VL - 86

SP - 1301

EP - 1313

JO - Animal Behaviour

JF - Animal Behaviour

SN - 0003-3472

IS - 6

ER -