Partnership in Initial Teacher Education in Scotland 1990-2005: unresolved tensions

Ian Smith, Estelle Brisard, Ian Menter

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The Second Stage Review of Initial Teacher Education (ITE) in Scotland leaves unresolved fundamental issues about ‘partnership’ within ITE. These have been sources of tension facing Scottish Higher Education (HE) providers attempting to develop models of partnership with schools and education authorities. This paper seeks to demonstrate a significant body of opinion among Scottish HE providers from the early 1990s wishing to progress innovation on partnership. It is suggested that the main barriers to innovation were the resistance of Scottish schoolteachers to accepting formalised, enhanced roles and responsibilities within partnership, and the failure of Scottish Ministers and administrations to place sustained discussion of underlying issues of partnership sufficiently high on the political agenda. The paper concludes that it will be essential to return to more fundamental discussion of the respective roles and responsibilities of HE staff and school staff within ITE partnership, and that the perspectives of research must be applied in such discussion.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)20-31
JournalScottish Educational Review
Issue number37
Publication statusPublished - 2006

Fingerprint

teacher
education
innovation
staff
responsibility
political agenda
school
minister

Cite this

Smith, Ian ; Brisard, Estelle ; Menter, Ian. / Partnership in Initial Teacher Education in Scotland 1990-2005 : unresolved tensions. In: Scottish Educational Review. 2006 ; No. 37. pp. 20-31.
@article{26b39c30f48144e7bb2b3eb23bcbd3b4,
title = "Partnership in Initial Teacher Education in Scotland 1990-2005: unresolved tensions",
abstract = "The Second Stage Review of Initial Teacher Education (ITE) in Scotland leaves unresolved fundamental issues about ‘partnership’ within ITE. These have been sources of tension facing Scottish Higher Education (HE) providers attempting to develop models of partnership with schools and education authorities. This paper seeks to demonstrate a significant body of opinion among Scottish HE providers from the early 1990s wishing to progress innovation on partnership. It is suggested that the main barriers to innovation were the resistance of Scottish schoolteachers to accepting formalised, enhanced roles and responsibilities within partnership, and the failure of Scottish Ministers and administrations to place sustained discussion of underlying issues of partnership sufficiently high on the political agenda. The paper concludes that it will be essential to return to more fundamental discussion of the respective roles and responsibilities of HE staff and school staff within ITE partnership, and that the perspectives of research must be applied in such discussion.",
author = "Ian Smith and Estelle Brisard and Ian Menter",
year = "2006",
language = "English",
pages = "20--31",
journal = "Scottish Educational Review",
issn = "0141-9072",
publisher = "Scottish Academic Press",
number = "37",

}

Partnership in Initial Teacher Education in Scotland 1990-2005 : unresolved tensions. / Smith, Ian; Brisard, Estelle; Menter, Ian.

In: Scottish Educational Review, No. 37, 2006, p. 20-31.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Partnership in Initial Teacher Education in Scotland 1990-2005

T2 - unresolved tensions

AU - Smith, Ian

AU - Brisard, Estelle

AU - Menter, Ian

PY - 2006

Y1 - 2006

N2 - The Second Stage Review of Initial Teacher Education (ITE) in Scotland leaves unresolved fundamental issues about ‘partnership’ within ITE. These have been sources of tension facing Scottish Higher Education (HE) providers attempting to develop models of partnership with schools and education authorities. This paper seeks to demonstrate a significant body of opinion among Scottish HE providers from the early 1990s wishing to progress innovation on partnership. It is suggested that the main barriers to innovation were the resistance of Scottish schoolteachers to accepting formalised, enhanced roles and responsibilities within partnership, and the failure of Scottish Ministers and administrations to place sustained discussion of underlying issues of partnership sufficiently high on the political agenda. The paper concludes that it will be essential to return to more fundamental discussion of the respective roles and responsibilities of HE staff and school staff within ITE partnership, and that the perspectives of research must be applied in such discussion.

AB - The Second Stage Review of Initial Teacher Education (ITE) in Scotland leaves unresolved fundamental issues about ‘partnership’ within ITE. These have been sources of tension facing Scottish Higher Education (HE) providers attempting to develop models of partnership with schools and education authorities. This paper seeks to demonstrate a significant body of opinion among Scottish HE providers from the early 1990s wishing to progress innovation on partnership. It is suggested that the main barriers to innovation were the resistance of Scottish schoolteachers to accepting formalised, enhanced roles and responsibilities within partnership, and the failure of Scottish Ministers and administrations to place sustained discussion of underlying issues of partnership sufficiently high on the political agenda. The paper concludes that it will be essential to return to more fundamental discussion of the respective roles and responsibilities of HE staff and school staff within ITE partnership, and that the perspectives of research must be applied in such discussion.

M3 - Article

SP - 20

EP - 31

JO - Scottish Educational Review

JF - Scottish Educational Review

SN - 0141-9072

IS - 37

ER -