Parents of excluded pupils: customers, partners, problems?

Anne Pirrie, Gale Macleod, Gillean McCluskey, Mairi Ann Cullen

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This article presents data drawn from interviews with a range of service
providers and with the parents of pupils permanently excluded from alternative
provision in England. The findings are considered in the context of recent policy
developments in the area of children and families. These include the neo-liberal
framing of parents as customers who are able and expected to exercise choice in
respect of their children’s education. We explore this notion with reference to
situations in which parents were confronted with very limited options. The interviews
with service providers illustrate the complex and contingent nature of
their relations with the parents, as well as fundamental inconsistencies in the
way the latter were regarded. It appeared that service providers’ perceptions
were partly shaped by the degree to which parents appeared to comply with
their suggestions, and by the level of resources (financial, personal and social)
parents had at their disposal. However, whether parents were perceived as customers,
partners or problems seemed largely contingent. The authors conclude
that it is in the complexities of the inter-relationships between service providers
and parents that the fault-lines of some of the key tenets of contemporary social
policy are revealed.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)387-401
Number of pages14
JournalEducational Review
Volume65
Issue number4
Publication statusPublished - 2012

Fingerprint

pupil
parents
customer
service provider
interview
resources
education

Cite this

Pirrie, A., Macleod, G., McCluskey, G., & Cullen, M. A. (2012). Parents of excluded pupils: customers, partners, problems? Educational Review, 65(4), 387-401.
Pirrie, Anne ; Macleod, Gale ; McCluskey, Gillean ; Cullen, Mairi Ann. / Parents of excluded pupils : customers, partners, problems?. In: Educational Review. 2012 ; Vol. 65, No. 4. pp. 387-401.
@article{9c8d4dd7bee746dda0a7685eb57a7e31,
title = "Parents of excluded pupils: customers, partners, problems?",
abstract = "This article presents data drawn from interviews with a range of serviceproviders and with the parents of pupils permanently excluded from alternativeprovision in England. The findings are considered in the context of recent policydevelopments in the area of children and families. These include the neo-liberalframing of parents as customers who are able and expected to exercise choice inrespect of their children’s education. We explore this notion with reference tosituations in which parents were confronted with very limited options. The interviewswith service providers illustrate the complex and contingent nature oftheir relations with the parents, as well as fundamental inconsistencies in theway the latter were regarded. It appeared that service providers’ perceptionswere partly shaped by the degree to which parents appeared to comply withtheir suggestions, and by the level of resources (financial, personal and social)parents had at their disposal. However, whether parents were perceived as customers,partners or problems seemed largely contingent. The authors concludethat it is in the complexities of the inter-relationships between service providersand parents that the fault-lines of some of the key tenets of contemporary socialpolicy are revealed.",
author = "Anne Pirrie and Gale Macleod and Gillean McCluskey and Cullen, {Mairi Ann}",
year = "2012",
language = "English",
volume = "65",
pages = "387--401",
journal = "Educational Review",
issn = "0013-1911",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",
number = "4",

}

Pirrie, A, Macleod, G, McCluskey, G & Cullen, MA 2012, 'Parents of excluded pupils: customers, partners, problems?' Educational Review, vol. 65, no. 4, pp. 387-401.

Parents of excluded pupils : customers, partners, problems? / Pirrie, Anne; Macleod, Gale; McCluskey, Gillean; Cullen, Mairi Ann.

In: Educational Review, Vol. 65, No. 4, 2012, p. 387-401.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Parents of excluded pupils

T2 - customers, partners, problems?

AU - Pirrie, Anne

AU - Macleod, Gale

AU - McCluskey, Gillean

AU - Cullen, Mairi Ann

PY - 2012

Y1 - 2012

N2 - This article presents data drawn from interviews with a range of serviceproviders and with the parents of pupils permanently excluded from alternativeprovision in England. The findings are considered in the context of recent policydevelopments in the area of children and families. These include the neo-liberalframing of parents as customers who are able and expected to exercise choice inrespect of their children’s education. We explore this notion with reference tosituations in which parents were confronted with very limited options. The interviewswith service providers illustrate the complex and contingent nature oftheir relations with the parents, as well as fundamental inconsistencies in theway the latter were regarded. It appeared that service providers’ perceptionswere partly shaped by the degree to which parents appeared to comply withtheir suggestions, and by the level of resources (financial, personal and social)parents had at their disposal. However, whether parents were perceived as customers,partners or problems seemed largely contingent. The authors concludethat it is in the complexities of the inter-relationships between service providersand parents that the fault-lines of some of the key tenets of contemporary socialpolicy are revealed.

AB - This article presents data drawn from interviews with a range of serviceproviders and with the parents of pupils permanently excluded from alternativeprovision in England. The findings are considered in the context of recent policydevelopments in the area of children and families. These include the neo-liberalframing of parents as customers who are able and expected to exercise choice inrespect of their children’s education. We explore this notion with reference tosituations in which parents were confronted with very limited options. The interviewswith service providers illustrate the complex and contingent nature oftheir relations with the parents, as well as fundamental inconsistencies in theway the latter were regarded. It appeared that service providers’ perceptionswere partly shaped by the degree to which parents appeared to comply withtheir suggestions, and by the level of resources (financial, personal and social)parents had at their disposal. However, whether parents were perceived as customers,partners or problems seemed largely contingent. The authors concludethat it is in the complexities of the inter-relationships between service providersand parents that the fault-lines of some of the key tenets of contemporary socialpolicy are revealed.

M3 - Article

VL - 65

SP - 387

EP - 401

JO - Educational Review

JF - Educational Review

SN - 0013-1911

IS - 4

ER -

Pirrie A, Macleod G, McCluskey G, Cullen MA. Parents of excluded pupils: customers, partners, problems? Educational Review. 2012;65(4):387-401.