Organisation development in HRM: a longitudinal study contrasting evolutionary trends between the UK and USA

Anne Clare Gillon, Ashley Braganza, Sharon Williams, Catherine McCauley-Smith

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Organisation development (OD) roles and skills are in demand in practice, yet they receive scant attention in the academic literature. Using the theoretical lens of population ecology, this study examines the evolution of OD through a 40-year empirical study. The paper extends current thinking by contrasting the research of academic scholars on the evolution of the human resources management (HRM) profession in the UK and USA. It also presents implications of the data for the future, in practice, and as an academic subject. The methodology applied in this longitudinal study identifies growth and content analysis of job advertisements in the relevant trade press. A key finding of the study is that whilst it has achieved legitimacy in UK practice, the growth in requirement for OD skills has largely been ignored by scholars. In its current evolutionary phase, the UK form of the profession has been in a stable state, however, a small number of HRM scholarly descriptions of new HRM' indicate that a further evolution in form has commenced. We argue that the most successful trajectory for evolving professional forms of HRM is through a convergence of HRM, OD and human resources development, and that UK scholars need to recognise the presence of OD in HRM.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1002-1023
JournalThe International Journal of Human Resource Management
Volume25
Issue number7
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 12 Apr 2014

Keywords

  • human resources
  • human resources development
  • human resources management
  • organisation development
  • population ecology

Cite this

@article{6047efc0a047478aac88bce76e3fcdcd,
title = "Organisation development in HRM: a longitudinal study contrasting evolutionary trends between the UK and USA",
abstract = "Organisation development (OD) roles and skills are in demand in practice, yet they receive scant attention in the academic literature. Using the theoretical lens of population ecology, this study examines the evolution of OD through a 40-year empirical study. The paper extends current thinking by contrasting the research of academic scholars on the evolution of the human resources management (HRM) profession in the UK and USA. It also presents implications of the data for the future, in practice, and as an academic subject. The methodology applied in this longitudinal study identifies growth and content analysis of job advertisements in the relevant trade press. A key finding of the study is that whilst it has achieved legitimacy in UK practice, the growth in requirement for OD skills has largely been ignored by scholars. In its current evolutionary phase, the UK form of the profession has been in a stable state, however, a small number of HRM scholarly descriptions of new HRM' indicate that a further evolution in form has commenced. We argue that the most successful trajectory for evolving professional forms of HRM is through a convergence of HRM, OD and human resources development, and that UK scholars need to recognise the presence of OD in HRM.",
keywords = "human resources, human resources development, human resources management, organisation development, population ecology",
author = "Gillon, {Anne Clare} and Ashley Braganza and Sharon Williams and Catherine McCauley-Smith",
year = "2014",
month = "4",
day = "12",
doi = "10.1080/09585192.2013.815252",
language = "English",
volume = "25",
pages = "1002--1023",
journal = "The International Journal of Human Resource Management",
issn = "0958-5192",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",
number = "7",

}

Organisation development in HRM: a longitudinal study contrasting evolutionary trends between the UK and USA. / Gillon, Anne Clare; Braganza, Ashley; Williams, Sharon; McCauley-Smith, Catherine.

In: The International Journal of Human Resource Management , Vol. 25, No. 7, 12.04.2014, p. 1002-1023.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Organisation development in HRM: a longitudinal study contrasting evolutionary trends between the UK and USA

AU - Gillon, Anne Clare

AU - Braganza, Ashley

AU - Williams, Sharon

AU - McCauley-Smith, Catherine

PY - 2014/4/12

Y1 - 2014/4/12

N2 - Organisation development (OD) roles and skills are in demand in practice, yet they receive scant attention in the academic literature. Using the theoretical lens of population ecology, this study examines the evolution of OD through a 40-year empirical study. The paper extends current thinking by contrasting the research of academic scholars on the evolution of the human resources management (HRM) profession in the UK and USA. It also presents implications of the data for the future, in practice, and as an academic subject. The methodology applied in this longitudinal study identifies growth and content analysis of job advertisements in the relevant trade press. A key finding of the study is that whilst it has achieved legitimacy in UK practice, the growth in requirement for OD skills has largely been ignored by scholars. In its current evolutionary phase, the UK form of the profession has been in a stable state, however, a small number of HRM scholarly descriptions of new HRM' indicate that a further evolution in form has commenced. We argue that the most successful trajectory for evolving professional forms of HRM is through a convergence of HRM, OD and human resources development, and that UK scholars need to recognise the presence of OD in HRM.

AB - Organisation development (OD) roles and skills are in demand in practice, yet they receive scant attention in the academic literature. Using the theoretical lens of population ecology, this study examines the evolution of OD through a 40-year empirical study. The paper extends current thinking by contrasting the research of academic scholars on the evolution of the human resources management (HRM) profession in the UK and USA. It also presents implications of the data for the future, in practice, and as an academic subject. The methodology applied in this longitudinal study identifies growth and content analysis of job advertisements in the relevant trade press. A key finding of the study is that whilst it has achieved legitimacy in UK practice, the growth in requirement for OD skills has largely been ignored by scholars. In its current evolutionary phase, the UK form of the profession has been in a stable state, however, a small number of HRM scholarly descriptions of new HRM' indicate that a further evolution in form has commenced. We argue that the most successful trajectory for evolving professional forms of HRM is through a convergence of HRM, OD and human resources development, and that UK scholars need to recognise the presence of OD in HRM.

KW - human resources

KW - human resources development

KW - human resources management

KW - organisation development

KW - population ecology

U2 - 10.1080/09585192.2013.815252

DO - 10.1080/09585192.2013.815252

M3 - Article

VL - 25

SP - 1002

EP - 1023

JO - The International Journal of Human Resource Management

JF - The International Journal of Human Resource Management

SN - 0958-5192

IS - 7

ER -