Neophyte experiences of football (soccer) match analysis

a multiple case study approach

Mark McKenna, Daryl Thomas Cowan, David Stevenson, Julien Steven Baker

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

42 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Performance analysis is extensively used in sport, but little is understood about its pedagogical application. Given its expanding role across football, this study explored the experiences of neophyte performance analysts. Squads across three professional football clubs were investigated as multiple cases of new match analysis. Six analysis interns were interviewed about their experiences after their first season, with archival data providing background information. Four themes emerged: (1) ‘building of relationships’ was important, along with established trust and role clarity; (2) ‘establishing an analysis system’ was difficult due to tacit coach knowledge, but analysis was established; (3) the quality of the ‘feedback process’ hinged on coaching styles, with balance of feedback and athlete engagement considered essential; (4) ‘establishing effect’ was complex with no statistical effects reported; yet enhanced relationships, role clarity, and improved performances were reported. Further investigations from coach and athlete perspectives are required.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)306-322
Number of pages17
JournalResearch in Sports Medicine
Volume26
Issue number3
Early online date5 Mar 2018
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 5 Mar 2018

Fingerprint

Soccer
Football
Athletes
Sports
Mentoring

Keywords

  • match analysis
  • analyst perceptions
  • video feedback
  • coach-athlete relationships
  • case study

Cite this

@article{acd1c124e4f64d499d1efd1617293fa8,
title = "Neophyte experiences of football (soccer) match analysis: a multiple case study approach",
abstract = "Performance analysis is extensively used in sport, but little is understood about its pedagogical application. Given its expanding role across football, this study explored the experiences of neophyte performance analysts. Squads across three professional football clubs were investigated as multiple cases of new match analysis. Six analysis interns were interviewed about their experiences after their first season, with archival data providing background information. Four themes emerged: (1) ‘building of relationships’ was important, along with established trust and role clarity; (2) ‘establishing an analysis system’ was difficult due to tacit coach knowledge, but analysis was established; (3) the quality of the ‘feedback process’ hinged on coaching styles, with balance of feedback and athlete engagement considered essential; (4) ‘establishing effect’ was complex with no statistical effects reported; yet enhanced relationships, role clarity, and improved performances were reported. Further investigations from coach and athlete perspectives are required.",
keywords = "match analysis, analyst perceptions, video feedback, coach-athlete relationships, case study",
author = "Mark McKenna and Cowan, {Daryl Thomas} and David Stevenson and Baker, {Julien Steven}",
year = "2018",
month = "3",
day = "5",
doi = "10.1080/15438627.2018.1447473",
language = "English",
volume = "26",
pages = "306--322",
journal = "Research in Sports Medicine",
issn = "1543-8627",
publisher = "Taylor & Francis",
number = "3",

}

Neophyte experiences of football (soccer) match analysis : a multiple case study approach. / McKenna, Mark; Cowan, Daryl Thomas; Stevenson, David; Baker, Julien Steven.

In: Research in Sports Medicine, Vol. 26, No. 3, 05.03.2018, p. 306-322.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Neophyte experiences of football (soccer) match analysis

T2 - a multiple case study approach

AU - McKenna, Mark

AU - Cowan, Daryl Thomas

AU - Stevenson, David

AU - Baker, Julien Steven

PY - 2018/3/5

Y1 - 2018/3/5

N2 - Performance analysis is extensively used in sport, but little is understood about its pedagogical application. Given its expanding role across football, this study explored the experiences of neophyte performance analysts. Squads across three professional football clubs were investigated as multiple cases of new match analysis. Six analysis interns were interviewed about their experiences after their first season, with archival data providing background information. Four themes emerged: (1) ‘building of relationships’ was important, along with established trust and role clarity; (2) ‘establishing an analysis system’ was difficult due to tacit coach knowledge, but analysis was established; (3) the quality of the ‘feedback process’ hinged on coaching styles, with balance of feedback and athlete engagement considered essential; (4) ‘establishing effect’ was complex with no statistical effects reported; yet enhanced relationships, role clarity, and improved performances were reported. Further investigations from coach and athlete perspectives are required.

AB - Performance analysis is extensively used in sport, but little is understood about its pedagogical application. Given its expanding role across football, this study explored the experiences of neophyte performance analysts. Squads across three professional football clubs were investigated as multiple cases of new match analysis. Six analysis interns were interviewed about their experiences after their first season, with archival data providing background information. Four themes emerged: (1) ‘building of relationships’ was important, along with established trust and role clarity; (2) ‘establishing an analysis system’ was difficult due to tacit coach knowledge, but analysis was established; (3) the quality of the ‘feedback process’ hinged on coaching styles, with balance of feedback and athlete engagement considered essential; (4) ‘establishing effect’ was complex with no statistical effects reported; yet enhanced relationships, role clarity, and improved performances were reported. Further investigations from coach and athlete perspectives are required.

KW - match analysis

KW - analyst perceptions

KW - video feedback

KW - coach-athlete relationships

KW - case study

U2 - 10.1080/15438627.2018.1447473

DO - 10.1080/15438627.2018.1447473

M3 - Article

VL - 26

SP - 306

EP - 322

JO - Research in Sports Medicine

JF - Research in Sports Medicine

SN - 1543-8627

IS - 3

ER -