Knowledge elicitation as an inquiring system: towards a 'subjective' knowledge elicitation methodology

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Many researchers in the field of knowledge elicitation (KE) have recognized the importance of the role of ‘expertise’ for the development of expert systems. This recognition has led to attempts to classify knowledge ‘types’ and define ‘genericxyr task structures so as to reduce the complexity of the KE process (Gammack & Young, 1985; Breuker & Wielinga, 1987; Welbank, 1987). The success of such an approach has been debatable as expertise has proved difficult to classify (Burton et al., 1987), with different researchers adopting different catagorizations. The research reported in this paper attempts to develop a broad view of ‘expertise’ by drawing upon Vicker's notion of ‘appreciation’ (1965). This, it is argued, can help to provide a useful description of the way in which expertise is gained and practised. The model suggested also takes into account the more ‘subjective’ aspects of human expertise (i.e. it allows for such components as intuition, personal experience and belief, bias and even prejudice). The view of expertise put forward is developed as a theoretical basis for a practical subjective approach to KE. As a result of this model, the author suggests that instead of concentrating upon the process of extraction, KE may be more usefully thought of as a process of inquiry through which, as described by Churchman (1971), knowledge, or expertise is produced. Some ideas that deal with ‘inquiring systems’ are examined here as an appropriate framework for the KE process.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)31-44
Number of pages14
JournalInformation Systems Journal
Volume2
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1992
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Knowledge acquisition
Expert systems

Keywords

  • Inquiring systems
  • knowledge elicitation

Cite this

@article{22d9f5171d834c8499d5b9e955763051,
title = "Knowledge elicitation as an inquiring system: towards a 'subjective' knowledge elicitation methodology",
abstract = "Many researchers in the field of knowledge elicitation (KE) have recognized the importance of the role of ‘expertise’ for the development of expert systems. This recognition has led to attempts to classify knowledge ‘types’ and define ‘genericxyr task structures so as to reduce the complexity of the KE process (Gammack & Young, 1985; Breuker & Wielinga, 1987; Welbank, 1987). The success of such an approach has been debatable as expertise has proved difficult to classify (Burton et al., 1987), with different researchers adopting different catagorizations. The research reported in this paper attempts to develop a broad view of ‘expertise’ by drawing upon Vicker's notion of ‘appreciation’ (1965). This, it is argued, can help to provide a useful description of the way in which expertise is gained and practised. The model suggested also takes into account the more ‘subjective’ aspects of human expertise (i.e. it allows for such components as intuition, personal experience and belief, bias and even prejudice). The view of expertise put forward is developed as a theoretical basis for a practical subjective approach to KE. As a result of this model, the author suggests that instead of concentrating upon the process of extraction, KE may be more usefully thought of as a process of inquiry through which, as described by Churchman (1971), knowledge, or expertise is produced. Some ideas that deal with ‘inquiring systems’ are examined here as an appropriate framework for the KE process.",
keywords = "Inquiring systems, knowledge elicitation",
author = "D. West",
year = "1992",
doi = "10.1111/j.1365-2575.1992.tb00065.x",
language = "English",
volume = "2",
pages = "31--44",
journal = "Information Systems Journal",
issn = "1365-2575",
publisher = "Wiley",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Knowledge elicitation as an inquiring system

T2 - towards a 'subjective' knowledge elicitation methodology

AU - West, D.

PY - 1992

Y1 - 1992

N2 - Many researchers in the field of knowledge elicitation (KE) have recognized the importance of the role of ‘expertise’ for the development of expert systems. This recognition has led to attempts to classify knowledge ‘types’ and define ‘genericxyr task structures so as to reduce the complexity of the KE process (Gammack & Young, 1985; Breuker & Wielinga, 1987; Welbank, 1987). The success of such an approach has been debatable as expertise has proved difficult to classify (Burton et al., 1987), with different researchers adopting different catagorizations. The research reported in this paper attempts to develop a broad view of ‘expertise’ by drawing upon Vicker's notion of ‘appreciation’ (1965). This, it is argued, can help to provide a useful description of the way in which expertise is gained and practised. The model suggested also takes into account the more ‘subjective’ aspects of human expertise (i.e. it allows for such components as intuition, personal experience and belief, bias and even prejudice). The view of expertise put forward is developed as a theoretical basis for a practical subjective approach to KE. As a result of this model, the author suggests that instead of concentrating upon the process of extraction, KE may be more usefully thought of as a process of inquiry through which, as described by Churchman (1971), knowledge, or expertise is produced. Some ideas that deal with ‘inquiring systems’ are examined here as an appropriate framework for the KE process.

AB - Many researchers in the field of knowledge elicitation (KE) have recognized the importance of the role of ‘expertise’ for the development of expert systems. This recognition has led to attempts to classify knowledge ‘types’ and define ‘genericxyr task structures so as to reduce the complexity of the KE process (Gammack & Young, 1985; Breuker & Wielinga, 1987; Welbank, 1987). The success of such an approach has been debatable as expertise has proved difficult to classify (Burton et al., 1987), with different researchers adopting different catagorizations. The research reported in this paper attempts to develop a broad view of ‘expertise’ by drawing upon Vicker's notion of ‘appreciation’ (1965). This, it is argued, can help to provide a useful description of the way in which expertise is gained and practised. The model suggested also takes into account the more ‘subjective’ aspects of human expertise (i.e. it allows for such components as intuition, personal experience and belief, bias and even prejudice). The view of expertise put forward is developed as a theoretical basis for a practical subjective approach to KE. As a result of this model, the author suggests that instead of concentrating upon the process of extraction, KE may be more usefully thought of as a process of inquiry through which, as described by Churchman (1971), knowledge, or expertise is produced. Some ideas that deal with ‘inquiring systems’ are examined here as an appropriate framework for the KE process.

KW - Inquiring systems

KW - knowledge elicitation

U2 - 10.1111/j.1365-2575.1992.tb00065.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1365-2575.1992.tb00065.x

M3 - Article

VL - 2

SP - 31

EP - 44

JO - Information Systems Journal

JF - Information Systems Journal

SN - 1365-2575

IS - 1

ER -