Investigating the Lived Experience of People with Down Syndrome with Dementia: Overcoming Methodological and Ethical Challenges

Karen Watchman

Research output: Contribution to journalSpecial issue

Abstract

Adults with Down syndrome are at increased risk of dementia at a significantly younger age and remain under-represented as participants
in dementia-related research. Because little is known about their personal experiences either immediately post-diagnosis or as
dementia progresses, there is little opportunity that shared individual experiences can shape future policy and practice. To remedy
this omission, the author examined methodological and ethical challenges identified as part of a research study that included people
with Down syndrome affected by dementia. It has been contended that traditional qualitative approaches are less effective when participants
are affected by changing cognitive functioning and reduced verbal communication. To counteract this contention overt participant
observation and an adapted narrative research method were used as part of a three-year longitudinal study to help better
understand the lived experiences of three adults with Down syndrome affected by dementia. Methodological and ethical challenges
were shown to collide, and factors contributing to this effect included identifying process consent, accurate representation of participants,
the role of and relationship with the researcher, participants, lack of awareness of their diagnosis of dementia, and need to recognize
the importance of social interaction while maintaining academic rigor. Reflections are proffered on two conceptual and
practice issues, with a call for both to be recognized and addressed in terms of future policy and practice. First is a lack of awareness
of a sense of “self” or identity, resulting in individuals with Down syndrome and dementia being defined by their situation rather
than individual preference or need. Second is the lack of information post-diagnosis about dementia being shared with people who
have Down syndrome
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)190
Number of pages198
JournalJournal of Policy and Practice in Intellectual Disabilities
Volume13
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jun 2016

Fingerprint

Down Syndrome
dementia
Dementia
experience
lack
Research
verbal communication
Interpersonal Relations
Longitudinal Studies
research method
longitudinal study
Communication
Research Personnel
narrative
interaction

Keywords

  • Down syndrome
  • Ageing
  • intellectual disabilities
  • Ethics

Cite this

@article{e89308be76e04424a4d3ce449555a349,
title = "Investigating the Lived Experience of People with Down Syndrome with Dementia: Overcoming Methodological and Ethical Challenges",
abstract = "Adults with Down syndrome are at increased risk of dementia at a significantly younger age and remain under-represented as participantsin dementia-related research. Because little is known about their personal experiences either immediately post-diagnosis or asdementia progresses, there is little opportunity that shared individual experiences can shape future policy and practice. To remedythis omission, the author examined methodological and ethical challenges identified as part of a research study that included peoplewith Down syndrome affected by dementia. It has been contended that traditional qualitative approaches are less effective when participantsare affected by changing cognitive functioning and reduced verbal communication. To counteract this contention overt participantobservation and an adapted narrative research method were used as part of a three-year longitudinal study to help betterunderstand the lived experiences of three adults with Down syndrome affected by dementia. Methodological and ethical challengeswere shown to collide, and factors contributing to this effect included identifying process consent, accurate representation of participants,the role of and relationship with the researcher, participants, lack of awareness of their diagnosis of dementia, and need to recognizethe importance of social interaction while maintaining academic rigor. Reflections are proffered on two conceptual andpractice issues, with a call for both to be recognized and addressed in terms of future policy and practice. First is a lack of awarenessof a sense of “self” or identity, resulting in individuals with Down syndrome and dementia being defined by their situation ratherthan individual preference or need. Second is the lack of information post-diagnosis about dementia being shared with people whohave Down syndrome",
keywords = "Down syndrome, Ageing, intellectual disabilities, Ethics",
author = "Karen Watchman",
year = "2016",
month = "6",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/jppi.12167",
language = "English",
volume = "13",
pages = "190",
journal = "Journal of Policy and Practice in Intellectual Disabilities",
issn = "1741-1122",
publisher = "Wiley",
number = "2",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Investigating the Lived Experience of People with Down Syndrome with Dementia: Overcoming Methodological and Ethical Challenges

AU - Watchman, Karen

PY - 2016/6/1

Y1 - 2016/6/1

N2 - Adults with Down syndrome are at increased risk of dementia at a significantly younger age and remain under-represented as participantsin dementia-related research. Because little is known about their personal experiences either immediately post-diagnosis or asdementia progresses, there is little opportunity that shared individual experiences can shape future policy and practice. To remedythis omission, the author examined methodological and ethical challenges identified as part of a research study that included peoplewith Down syndrome affected by dementia. It has been contended that traditional qualitative approaches are less effective when participantsare affected by changing cognitive functioning and reduced verbal communication. To counteract this contention overt participantobservation and an adapted narrative research method were used as part of a three-year longitudinal study to help betterunderstand the lived experiences of three adults with Down syndrome affected by dementia. Methodological and ethical challengeswere shown to collide, and factors contributing to this effect included identifying process consent, accurate representation of participants,the role of and relationship with the researcher, participants, lack of awareness of their diagnosis of dementia, and need to recognizethe importance of social interaction while maintaining academic rigor. Reflections are proffered on two conceptual andpractice issues, with a call for both to be recognized and addressed in terms of future policy and practice. First is a lack of awarenessof a sense of “self” or identity, resulting in individuals with Down syndrome and dementia being defined by their situation ratherthan individual preference or need. Second is the lack of information post-diagnosis about dementia being shared with people whohave Down syndrome

AB - Adults with Down syndrome are at increased risk of dementia at a significantly younger age and remain under-represented as participantsin dementia-related research. Because little is known about their personal experiences either immediately post-diagnosis or asdementia progresses, there is little opportunity that shared individual experiences can shape future policy and practice. To remedythis omission, the author examined methodological and ethical challenges identified as part of a research study that included peoplewith Down syndrome affected by dementia. It has been contended that traditional qualitative approaches are less effective when participantsare affected by changing cognitive functioning and reduced verbal communication. To counteract this contention overt participantobservation and an adapted narrative research method were used as part of a three-year longitudinal study to help betterunderstand the lived experiences of three adults with Down syndrome affected by dementia. Methodological and ethical challengeswere shown to collide, and factors contributing to this effect included identifying process consent, accurate representation of participants,the role of and relationship with the researcher, participants, lack of awareness of their diagnosis of dementia, and need to recognizethe importance of social interaction while maintaining academic rigor. Reflections are proffered on two conceptual andpractice issues, with a call for both to be recognized and addressed in terms of future policy and practice. First is a lack of awarenessof a sense of “self” or identity, resulting in individuals with Down syndrome and dementia being defined by their situation ratherthan individual preference or need. Second is the lack of information post-diagnosis about dementia being shared with people whohave Down syndrome

KW - Down syndrome

KW - Ageing

KW - intellectual disabilities

KW - Ethics

U2 - 10.1111/jppi.12167

DO - 10.1111/jppi.12167

M3 - Special issue

VL - 13

SP - 190

JO - Journal of Policy and Practice in Intellectual Disabilities

JF - Journal of Policy and Practice in Intellectual Disabilities

SN - 1741-1122

IS - 2

ER -