Guanxi dynamics and identity construction: An interpretive look at the Chinese professional service firms

Katarzyna Kosmala, Chunyan Xian

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Purpose – This study aims to examine aspects of the construction of professional identity, based on an interpretative inquiry in two Chinese professional service firms in Beijing.

Design/methodology/approach – Data were gathered through participant observation, archival material and interviews. The interpretive nature of the research experience facilitated openness to the local field and avoidance of a heavy reliance on assumptions that derive from privileging the Western constructions of professional identity, where “I” (the researcher) am situated epistemologically.

Findings – Professionalism discourse, a powerful resource of ambiguity, becomes an arena where identity is “asserted” through organisational performance, incorporated in normative Western‐driven laws. Enacted professionalism appears consistent with the pursuit of an elevated Western image. The relationships with the clients, however, are embedded in guanxi dynamics and related accountabilities, reflecting the local ways of doing things.

Originality/value – Empirical material offers insights into professionalisation processes in Chinese firms, with a focus on the construction of professional identity, located within organisational micro‐dynamics.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)202-223
Number of pages22
JournalCritical Perspectives on International Business
Volume7
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2011

Fingerprint

Guanxi
Professional identity
Interpretive
Identity construction
Professional service firms
Professionalism
Organizational performance
Accountability
Resources
Participant observation
Discourse
Openness
Avoidance
Design methodology
Beijing
Chinese firms
Professionalization

Cite this

@article{0db4040b32874bb48aac0a7326ce0d2e,
title = "Guanxi dynamics and identity construction: An interpretive look at the Chinese professional service firms",
abstract = "Purpose – This study aims to examine aspects of the construction of professional identity, based on an interpretative inquiry in two Chinese professional service firms in Beijing.Design/methodology/approach – Data were gathered through participant observation, archival material and interviews. The interpretive nature of the research experience facilitated openness to the local field and avoidance of a heavy reliance on assumptions that derive from privileging the Western constructions of professional identity, where “I” (the researcher) am situated epistemologically.Findings – Professionalism discourse, a powerful resource of ambiguity, becomes an arena where identity is “asserted” through organisational performance, incorporated in normative Western‐driven laws. Enacted professionalism appears consistent with the pursuit of an elevated Western image. The relationships with the clients, however, are embedded in guanxi dynamics and related accountabilities, reflecting the local ways of doing things.Originality/value – Empirical material offers insights into professionalisation processes in Chinese firms, with a focus on the construction of professional identity, located within organisational micro‐dynamics.",
author = "Katarzyna Kosmala and Chunyan Xian",
year = "2011",
doi = "10.1108/17422041111149507",
language = "English",
volume = "7",
pages = "202--223",
journal = "Critical Perspectives on International Business",
issn = "1758-6062",
publisher = "Emerald Publishing Limited",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Guanxi dynamics and identity construction

T2 - An interpretive look at the Chinese professional service firms

AU - Kosmala, Katarzyna

AU - Xian, Chunyan

PY - 2011

Y1 - 2011

N2 - Purpose – This study aims to examine aspects of the construction of professional identity, based on an interpretative inquiry in two Chinese professional service firms in Beijing.Design/methodology/approach – Data were gathered through participant observation, archival material and interviews. The interpretive nature of the research experience facilitated openness to the local field and avoidance of a heavy reliance on assumptions that derive from privileging the Western constructions of professional identity, where “I” (the researcher) am situated epistemologically.Findings – Professionalism discourse, a powerful resource of ambiguity, becomes an arena where identity is “asserted” through organisational performance, incorporated in normative Western‐driven laws. Enacted professionalism appears consistent with the pursuit of an elevated Western image. The relationships with the clients, however, are embedded in guanxi dynamics and related accountabilities, reflecting the local ways of doing things.Originality/value – Empirical material offers insights into professionalisation processes in Chinese firms, with a focus on the construction of professional identity, located within organisational micro‐dynamics.

AB - Purpose – This study aims to examine aspects of the construction of professional identity, based on an interpretative inquiry in two Chinese professional service firms in Beijing.Design/methodology/approach – Data were gathered through participant observation, archival material and interviews. The interpretive nature of the research experience facilitated openness to the local field and avoidance of a heavy reliance on assumptions that derive from privileging the Western constructions of professional identity, where “I” (the researcher) am situated epistemologically.Findings – Professionalism discourse, a powerful resource of ambiguity, becomes an arena where identity is “asserted” through organisational performance, incorporated in normative Western‐driven laws. Enacted professionalism appears consistent with the pursuit of an elevated Western image. The relationships with the clients, however, are embedded in guanxi dynamics and related accountabilities, reflecting the local ways of doing things.Originality/value – Empirical material offers insights into professionalisation processes in Chinese firms, with a focus on the construction of professional identity, located within organisational micro‐dynamics.

U2 - 10.1108/17422041111149507

DO - 10.1108/17422041111149507

M3 - Article

VL - 7

SP - 202

EP - 223

JO - Critical Perspectives on International Business

JF - Critical Perspectives on International Business

SN - 1758-6062

IS - 3

ER -