From a distance: researching across jurisdictions in the UK

Anne Pirrie, Gale Macleod

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This paper explores the challenges of negotiating access to research participants at a
distance. These challenges are explored in the context of a study of destinations and
outcomes for 24 young people permanently excluded from special schools and Pupil
Referral Units (PRUs) in England. The authors describe the process of negotiating
access through a third party to young people considered to be particularly vulnerable,
from whom written opt-in consent was negotiated through an intermediary. This process
necessitated establishing trust with a wide range of service providers, usually over the
telephone. Moreover, these service providers were gatekeepers and informants to the
research. They were located at different points in a variety of professional hierarchies
with different accountability structures. There was considerable variation in the extent to
which the individuals themselves were prepared to exercise trust, defined here as both
cognitive and behavioural. The responses of these individuals were contingent and
unpredictable. The research team negotiated this uncertain territory as insiders with
knowledge and experience of alternative provision, and as outsiders by virtue of their
location in another jurisdiction of the UK.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)60-70
Number of pages10
JournalScottish Educational Review
Volume42
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - 2010

Fingerprint

service provider
jurisdiction
gatekeeper
responsibility
school
experience

Cite this

@article{15896f3367ed4f64a19ef390a7dd471c,
title = "From a distance: researching across jurisdictions in the UK",
abstract = "This paper explores the challenges of negotiating access to research participants at adistance. These challenges are explored in the context of a study of destinations andoutcomes for 24 young people permanently excluded from special schools and PupilReferral Units (PRUs) in England. The authors describe the process of negotiatingaccess through a third party to young people considered to be particularly vulnerable,from whom written opt-in consent was negotiated through an intermediary. This processnecessitated establishing trust with a wide range of service providers, usually over thetelephone. Moreover, these service providers were gatekeepers and informants to theresearch. They were located at different points in a variety of professional hierarchieswith different accountability structures. There was considerable variation in the extent towhich the individuals themselves were prepared to exercise trust, defined here as bothcognitive and behavioural. The responses of these individuals were contingent andunpredictable. The research team negotiated this uncertain territory as insiders withknowledge and experience of alternative provision, and as outsiders by virtue of theirlocation in another jurisdiction of the UK.",
author = "Anne Pirrie and Gale Macleod",
year = "2010",
language = "English",
volume = "42",
pages = "60--70",
journal = "Scottish Educational Review",
issn = "0141-9072",
publisher = "Scottish Academic Press",
number = "1",

}

From a distance : researching across jurisdictions in the UK. / Pirrie, Anne; Macleod, Gale.

In: Scottish Educational Review, Vol. 42, No. 1, 2010, p. 60-70.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - From a distance

T2 - researching across jurisdictions in the UK

AU - Pirrie, Anne

AU - Macleod, Gale

PY - 2010

Y1 - 2010

N2 - This paper explores the challenges of negotiating access to research participants at adistance. These challenges are explored in the context of a study of destinations andoutcomes for 24 young people permanently excluded from special schools and PupilReferral Units (PRUs) in England. The authors describe the process of negotiatingaccess through a third party to young people considered to be particularly vulnerable,from whom written opt-in consent was negotiated through an intermediary. This processnecessitated establishing trust with a wide range of service providers, usually over thetelephone. Moreover, these service providers were gatekeepers and informants to theresearch. They were located at different points in a variety of professional hierarchieswith different accountability structures. There was considerable variation in the extent towhich the individuals themselves were prepared to exercise trust, defined here as bothcognitive and behavioural. The responses of these individuals were contingent andunpredictable. The research team negotiated this uncertain territory as insiders withknowledge and experience of alternative provision, and as outsiders by virtue of theirlocation in another jurisdiction of the UK.

AB - This paper explores the challenges of negotiating access to research participants at adistance. These challenges are explored in the context of a study of destinations andoutcomes for 24 young people permanently excluded from special schools and PupilReferral Units (PRUs) in England. The authors describe the process of negotiatingaccess through a third party to young people considered to be particularly vulnerable,from whom written opt-in consent was negotiated through an intermediary. This processnecessitated establishing trust with a wide range of service providers, usually over thetelephone. Moreover, these service providers were gatekeepers and informants to theresearch. They were located at different points in a variety of professional hierarchieswith different accountability structures. There was considerable variation in the extent towhich the individuals themselves were prepared to exercise trust, defined here as bothcognitive and behavioural. The responses of these individuals were contingent andunpredictable. The research team negotiated this uncertain territory as insiders withknowledge and experience of alternative provision, and as outsiders by virtue of theirlocation in another jurisdiction of the UK.

M3 - Article

VL - 42

SP - 60

EP - 70

JO - Scottish Educational Review

JF - Scottish Educational Review

SN - 0141-9072

IS - 1

ER -