Experimental cyclic performance of cold-formed steel bolted moment resisting frames

Daniel P. McCrum, Jordan Simon, Michael Grimes, Brian M. Broderick, James B.P. Lim, Andrzej M. Wrzesien

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This paper investigates the seismic performance of a single storey moment resisting cold-formed steel (CFS) portal frame through cyclic testing. Six monotonic and six cyclic tests were performed on three different section sizes of CFS. The portal frames were 3.2 m long × 2.2 m high and the CFS sections bolted with either perfect-fit tolerance bolt holes (PTBH) or normal tolerance bolt holes (NTBH) connections. Connections with NTBH are standard in CFS, but connections with PTBH are often only used for short-spanning frames. Results from the tests demonstrated that both PTBH and NTBH connections had stable hysteresis and good hysteretic energy dissipation capacity and ductility. On average, the NTBH connections performed better under cyclic loading in comparison to the PTBH connections (5.4% larger ductility and 22.3% increased energy dissipation). Strain gauge results show failure due to combined bending and bi-moment stresses, of which the bi-moment stress component accounted for 41% of the total longitudinal stresses at the section web. It should be noted that bi-moment stresses are often incorrectly ignored by practitioners; the experimental test results thus show that by doing so the sections would fail at 59% of the design moment. Initial failure was localised at the top of the column sections in the form of local buckling at the web-to-flange junction under compressive stresses. Several load cycles past the initial buckling stage led to a further reduction of steel ductility due to strain hardening and strain ageing leading to fracture of the steel in the section corners. The buckling/tearing failure in the columns would result in a reduced axial load carrying capacity.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1-14
Number of pages14
JournalEngineering Structures
Volume181
Early online date8 Dec 2018
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 15 Feb 2019

Fingerprint

Bolts
Steel
Buckling
Ductility
Energy dissipation
Axial loads
Load limits
Flanges
Strain gages
Compressive stress
Strain hardening
Hysteresis
Loads (forces)
Aging of materials
Testing

Keywords

  • Cold-formed steel portal frames
  • Cyclic testing
  • Moment resisting frame
  • Connections with perfect-fit tolerance bolt holes
  • Connection with normal tolerance bolt holes

Cite this

McCrum, Daniel P. ; Simon, Jordan ; Grimes, Michael ; Broderick, Brian M. ; Lim, James B.P. ; Wrzesien, Andrzej M. / Experimental cyclic performance of cold-formed steel bolted moment resisting frames. In: Engineering Structures. 2019 ; Vol. 181. pp. 1-14.
@article{1fab5801d20e45df97039cd827afdd0c,
title = "Experimental cyclic performance of cold-formed steel bolted moment resisting frames",
abstract = "This paper investigates the seismic performance of a single storey moment resisting cold-formed steel (CFS) portal frame through cyclic testing. Six monotonic and six cyclic tests were performed on three different section sizes of CFS. The portal frames were 3.2 m long × 2.2 m high and the CFS sections bolted with either perfect-fit tolerance bolt holes (PTBH) or normal tolerance bolt holes (NTBH) connections. Connections with NTBH are standard in CFS, but connections with PTBH are often only used for short-spanning frames. Results from the tests demonstrated that both PTBH and NTBH connections had stable hysteresis and good hysteretic energy dissipation capacity and ductility. On average, the NTBH connections performed better under cyclic loading in comparison to the PTBH connections (5.4{\%} larger ductility and 22.3{\%} increased energy dissipation). Strain gauge results show failure due to combined bending and bi-moment stresses, of which the bi-moment stress component accounted for 41{\%} of the total longitudinal stresses at the section web. It should be noted that bi-moment stresses are often incorrectly ignored by practitioners; the experimental test results thus show that by doing so the sections would fail at 59{\%} of the design moment. Initial failure was localised at the top of the column sections in the form of local buckling at the web-to-flange junction under compressive stresses. Several load cycles past the initial buckling stage led to a further reduction of steel ductility due to strain hardening and strain ageing leading to fracture of the steel in the section corners. The buckling/tearing failure in the columns would result in a reduced axial load carrying capacity.",
keywords = "Cold-formed steel portal frames, Cyclic testing, Moment resisting frame, Connections with perfect-fit tolerance bolt holes, Connection with normal tolerance bolt holes",
author = "McCrum, {Daniel P.} and Jordan Simon and Michael Grimes and Broderick, {Brian M.} and Lim, {James B.P.} and Wrzesien, {Andrzej M.}",
year = "2019",
month = "2",
day = "15",
doi = "10.1016/j.engstruct.2018.11.063",
language = "English",
volume = "181",
pages = "1--14",
journal = "Engineering Structures",
issn = "0141-0296",
publisher = "Elsevier B.V.",

}

Experimental cyclic performance of cold-formed steel bolted moment resisting frames. / McCrum, Daniel P.; Simon, Jordan; Grimes, Michael; Broderick, Brian M.; Lim, James B.P.; Wrzesien, Andrzej M.

In: Engineering Structures, Vol. 181, 15.02.2019, p. 1-14.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Experimental cyclic performance of cold-formed steel bolted moment resisting frames

AU - McCrum, Daniel P.

AU - Simon, Jordan

AU - Grimes, Michael

AU - Broderick, Brian M.

AU - Lim, James B.P.

AU - Wrzesien, Andrzej M.

PY - 2019/2/15

Y1 - 2019/2/15

N2 - This paper investigates the seismic performance of a single storey moment resisting cold-formed steel (CFS) portal frame through cyclic testing. Six monotonic and six cyclic tests were performed on three different section sizes of CFS. The portal frames were 3.2 m long × 2.2 m high and the CFS sections bolted with either perfect-fit tolerance bolt holes (PTBH) or normal tolerance bolt holes (NTBH) connections. Connections with NTBH are standard in CFS, but connections with PTBH are often only used for short-spanning frames. Results from the tests demonstrated that both PTBH and NTBH connections had stable hysteresis and good hysteretic energy dissipation capacity and ductility. On average, the NTBH connections performed better under cyclic loading in comparison to the PTBH connections (5.4% larger ductility and 22.3% increased energy dissipation). Strain gauge results show failure due to combined bending and bi-moment stresses, of which the bi-moment stress component accounted for 41% of the total longitudinal stresses at the section web. It should be noted that bi-moment stresses are often incorrectly ignored by practitioners; the experimental test results thus show that by doing so the sections would fail at 59% of the design moment. Initial failure was localised at the top of the column sections in the form of local buckling at the web-to-flange junction under compressive stresses. Several load cycles past the initial buckling stage led to a further reduction of steel ductility due to strain hardening and strain ageing leading to fracture of the steel in the section corners. The buckling/tearing failure in the columns would result in a reduced axial load carrying capacity.

AB - This paper investigates the seismic performance of a single storey moment resisting cold-formed steel (CFS) portal frame through cyclic testing. Six monotonic and six cyclic tests were performed on three different section sizes of CFS. The portal frames were 3.2 m long × 2.2 m high and the CFS sections bolted with either perfect-fit tolerance bolt holes (PTBH) or normal tolerance bolt holes (NTBH) connections. Connections with NTBH are standard in CFS, but connections with PTBH are often only used for short-spanning frames. Results from the tests demonstrated that both PTBH and NTBH connections had stable hysteresis and good hysteretic energy dissipation capacity and ductility. On average, the NTBH connections performed better under cyclic loading in comparison to the PTBH connections (5.4% larger ductility and 22.3% increased energy dissipation). Strain gauge results show failure due to combined bending and bi-moment stresses, of which the bi-moment stress component accounted for 41% of the total longitudinal stresses at the section web. It should be noted that bi-moment stresses are often incorrectly ignored by practitioners; the experimental test results thus show that by doing so the sections would fail at 59% of the design moment. Initial failure was localised at the top of the column sections in the form of local buckling at the web-to-flange junction under compressive stresses. Several load cycles past the initial buckling stage led to a further reduction of steel ductility due to strain hardening and strain ageing leading to fracture of the steel in the section corners. The buckling/tearing failure in the columns would result in a reduced axial load carrying capacity.

KW - Cold-formed steel portal frames

KW - Cyclic testing

KW - Moment resisting frame

KW - Connections with perfect-fit tolerance bolt holes

KW - Connection with normal tolerance bolt holes

U2 - 10.1016/j.engstruct.2018.11.063

DO - 10.1016/j.engstruct.2018.11.063

M3 - Article

VL - 181

SP - 1

EP - 14

JO - Engineering Structures

JF - Engineering Structures

SN - 0141-0296

ER -