Documenting the UK “Black Fish Scandal” as a case study of criminal entrepreneurship

Robert Smith

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Purpose
– The purpose of this paper is to consider the industrial exploitation of fishing quotas as a case of organized criminal entrepreneurship. Seldom is consideration given to the existence of informal and criminal entrepreneurship within the fishing industry. Consequentially, this case charts the “Black Fish Scandal” in the UK which saw the flouting of regulations and quotas on a commercial scale netting the protagonists £63 million through the illegal landing of undeclared fish.

Design/methodology/approach
– The case study underpinning this paper is constructed using documentary research techniques.

Findings
– Entrepreneurship can be destructive in a Baumolian sense as well as being productive. The moral of the story is that the entrepreneurs involved in the scandal are primarily small businessmen and not organized criminals; and that lessons can be learned from this case on how knowledge of entrepreneurship can be used to ensure that entrepreneurs and businessmen are not tempted to stray into the commission of economic crime.

Research limitations/implications
– A limitation of the study is that it was constructed solely from media reports of the scandal. The implications of this study are widespread for politicians, local government, policy makers and academic researchers alike and highlight the rise and fall of an industry and the impact of “laissez-faire” entrepreneurship on the industry suggesting to politicians, local government, policy makers that there needs to be a more planned approach to encouraging entrepreneurship within such coastal communities.

Originality/value
– This case based empirical study is of value because it is one of the first known UK studies of the Black Fish Scandal.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)199-221
Number of pages23
JournalInternational Journal of Sociology and Social Policy
Volume35
Issue number3/4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2015

Fingerprint

scandal
entrepreneurship
local politician
businessman
entrepreneur
government policy
industry
research method
Entrepreneurship
Scandal
exploitation
offense
regulation
Politicians
methodology
community
economics
Values

Keywords

  • entrepreneurship
  • business ethics
  • criminal entrepreneurship
  • illegal fishing

Cite this

@article{bbad0044d3604634931d070b1e109e43,
title = "Documenting the UK “Black Fish Scandal” as a case study of criminal entrepreneurship",
abstract = "Purpose– The purpose of this paper is to consider the industrial exploitation of fishing quotas as a case of organized criminal entrepreneurship. Seldom is consideration given to the existence of informal and criminal entrepreneurship within the fishing industry. Consequentially, this case charts the “Black Fish Scandal” in the UK which saw the flouting of regulations and quotas on a commercial scale netting the protagonists £63 million through the illegal landing of undeclared fish.Design/methodology/approach– The case study underpinning this paper is constructed using documentary research techniques.Findings– Entrepreneurship can be destructive in a Baumolian sense as well as being productive. The moral of the story is that the entrepreneurs involved in the scandal are primarily small businessmen and not organized criminals; and that lessons can be learned from this case on how knowledge of entrepreneurship can be used to ensure that entrepreneurs and businessmen are not tempted to stray into the commission of economic crime.Research limitations/implications– A limitation of the study is that it was constructed solely from media reports of the scandal. The implications of this study are widespread for politicians, local government, policy makers and academic researchers alike and highlight the rise and fall of an industry and the impact of “laissez-faire” entrepreneurship on the industry suggesting to politicians, local government, policy makers that there needs to be a more planned approach to encouraging entrepreneurship within such coastal communities.Originality/value– This case based empirical study is of value because it is one of the first known UK studies of the Black Fish Scandal.",
keywords = "entrepreneurship, business ethics, criminal entrepreneurship, illegal fishing",
author = "Robert Smith",
year = "2015",
doi = "10.1108/IJSSP-02-2014-0018",
language = "English",
volume = "35",
pages = "199--221",
journal = "International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy",
issn = "0144-333X",
publisher = "Emerald Publishing Limited",
number = "3/4",

}

Documenting the UK “Black Fish Scandal” as a case study of criminal entrepreneurship. / Smith, Robert.

In: International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, Vol. 35, No. 3/4, 2015, p. 199-221.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Documenting the UK “Black Fish Scandal” as a case study of criminal entrepreneurship

AU - Smith, Robert

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - Purpose– The purpose of this paper is to consider the industrial exploitation of fishing quotas as a case of organized criminal entrepreneurship. Seldom is consideration given to the existence of informal and criminal entrepreneurship within the fishing industry. Consequentially, this case charts the “Black Fish Scandal” in the UK which saw the flouting of regulations and quotas on a commercial scale netting the protagonists £63 million through the illegal landing of undeclared fish.Design/methodology/approach– The case study underpinning this paper is constructed using documentary research techniques.Findings– Entrepreneurship can be destructive in a Baumolian sense as well as being productive. The moral of the story is that the entrepreneurs involved in the scandal are primarily small businessmen and not organized criminals; and that lessons can be learned from this case on how knowledge of entrepreneurship can be used to ensure that entrepreneurs and businessmen are not tempted to stray into the commission of economic crime.Research limitations/implications– A limitation of the study is that it was constructed solely from media reports of the scandal. The implications of this study are widespread for politicians, local government, policy makers and academic researchers alike and highlight the rise and fall of an industry and the impact of “laissez-faire” entrepreneurship on the industry suggesting to politicians, local government, policy makers that there needs to be a more planned approach to encouraging entrepreneurship within such coastal communities.Originality/value– This case based empirical study is of value because it is one of the first known UK studies of the Black Fish Scandal.

AB - Purpose– The purpose of this paper is to consider the industrial exploitation of fishing quotas as a case of organized criminal entrepreneurship. Seldom is consideration given to the existence of informal and criminal entrepreneurship within the fishing industry. Consequentially, this case charts the “Black Fish Scandal” in the UK which saw the flouting of regulations and quotas on a commercial scale netting the protagonists £63 million through the illegal landing of undeclared fish.Design/methodology/approach– The case study underpinning this paper is constructed using documentary research techniques.Findings– Entrepreneurship can be destructive in a Baumolian sense as well as being productive. The moral of the story is that the entrepreneurs involved in the scandal are primarily small businessmen and not organized criminals; and that lessons can be learned from this case on how knowledge of entrepreneurship can be used to ensure that entrepreneurs and businessmen are not tempted to stray into the commission of economic crime.Research limitations/implications– A limitation of the study is that it was constructed solely from media reports of the scandal. The implications of this study are widespread for politicians, local government, policy makers and academic researchers alike and highlight the rise and fall of an industry and the impact of “laissez-faire” entrepreneurship on the industry suggesting to politicians, local government, policy makers that there needs to be a more planned approach to encouraging entrepreneurship within such coastal communities.Originality/value– This case based empirical study is of value because it is one of the first known UK studies of the Black Fish Scandal.

KW - entrepreneurship

KW - business ethics

KW - criminal entrepreneurship

KW - illegal fishing

U2 - 10.1108/IJSSP-02-2014-0018

DO - 10.1108/IJSSP-02-2014-0018

M3 - Article

VL - 35

SP - 199

EP - 221

JO - International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy

JF - International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy

SN - 0144-333X

IS - 3/4

ER -