Belief in animal mind among Spanish primary school children

David José Menor-Campus, Roxanne Hawkins, Joanne Williams

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Beliefs concerning the mental experiences of nonhuman animals have been related to how people treat, see, and take care of nonhuman animals. Whereas this issue has been the subject of several studies on adults, few have been conducted with children. Taking advantage of a recently published scale, the Child-BAM questionnaire, we aimed to explore the beliefs in animal minds of Spanish primary school children. The study also considered the effects of a child's age, school year group, gender, and pet ownership on their beliefs in animal mind. The Child-BAM questionnaire, concerning the mental capabilities of eight different species (human, chimpanzee, dog, cow, otter, sparrow, frog, and fish), was distributed at a primary school sited in Cordoba, Spain. A total of 416 participants were included aged between 6 and 13 years. Each child provided scores for animals’ ability to have intelligence, experience pain, fear, happiness, and sadness, and total scores for the eight species were calculated. The results showed that children's beliefs about animal minds differed depending on the type of animal, and that children were more likely to believe in the emotional capacities of animals rather than their cognitive capabilities. Dogs achieved similar scores to humans regarding all capabilities, and higher than any other species, while the cow, fish, and frog generally scored the lowest. Age, school year group, and having a companion animal at home affected beliefs in animal minds, whereas gender had no effect. This study highlights cultural similarities in children's beliefs about animal minds and the potential importance of this variable for future research in child–animal interactions.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)599-614
Number of pages16
JournalAnthrozoös
Volume31
Issue number5
Early online date19 Sep 2018
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 19 Sep 2018
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Pets
Anura
Fishes
Otters
Dogs
Sparrows
Happiness
Aptitude
Pan troglodytes
Ownership
Intelligence
Spain
Fear
Pain
Surveys and Questionnaires

Keywords

  • animals
  • belief in animal mind
  • Child-BAM
  • children
  • human-animal interaction
  • sentience
  • Spanish

Cite this

Menor-Campus, David José ; Hawkins, Roxanne ; Joanne Williams. / Belief in animal mind among Spanish primary school children. In: Anthrozoös. 2018 ; Vol. 31, No. 5. pp. 599-614.
@article{af89f55575ff46509e95f254519f1546,
title = "Belief in animal mind among Spanish primary school children",
abstract = "Beliefs concerning the mental experiences of nonhuman animals have been related to how people treat, see, and take care of nonhuman animals. Whereas this issue has been the subject of several studies on adults, few have been conducted with children. Taking advantage of a recently published scale, the Child-BAM questionnaire, we aimed to explore the beliefs in animal minds of Spanish primary school children. The study also considered the effects of a child's age, school year group, gender, and pet ownership on their beliefs in animal mind. The Child-BAM questionnaire, concerning the mental capabilities of eight different species (human, chimpanzee, dog, cow, otter, sparrow, frog, and fish), was distributed at a primary school sited in Cordoba, Spain. A total of 416 participants were included aged between 6 and 13 years. Each child provided scores for animals’ ability to have intelligence, experience pain, fear, happiness, and sadness, and total scores for the eight species were calculated. The results showed that children's beliefs about animal minds differed depending on the type of animal, and that children were more likely to believe in the emotional capacities of animals rather than their cognitive capabilities. Dogs achieved similar scores to humans regarding all capabilities, and higher than any other species, while the cow, fish, and frog generally scored the lowest. Age, school year group, and having a companion animal at home affected beliefs in animal minds, whereas gender had no effect. This study highlights cultural similarities in children's beliefs about animal minds and the potential importance of this variable for future research in child–animal interactions.",
keywords = "animals, belief in animal mind, Child-BAM, children, human-animal interaction, sentience, Spanish",
author = "Menor-Campus, {David Jos{\'e}} and Roxanne Hawkins and {Joanne Williams}",
year = "2018",
month = "9",
day = "19",
doi = "10.1080/08927936.2018.1505340",
language = "English",
volume = "31",
pages = "599--614",
journal = "Anthrozo{\"o}s",
issn = "0892-7936",
publisher = "Routledge Taylor & Francis Group",
number = "5",

}

Belief in animal mind among Spanish primary school children. / Menor-Campus, David José; Hawkins, Roxanne; Joanne Williams.

In: Anthrozoös, Vol. 31, No. 5, 19.09.2018, p. 599-614.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Belief in animal mind among Spanish primary school children

AU - Menor-Campus, David José

AU - Hawkins, Roxanne

AU - Joanne Williams

PY - 2018/9/19

Y1 - 2018/9/19

N2 - Beliefs concerning the mental experiences of nonhuman animals have been related to how people treat, see, and take care of nonhuman animals. Whereas this issue has been the subject of several studies on adults, few have been conducted with children. Taking advantage of a recently published scale, the Child-BAM questionnaire, we aimed to explore the beliefs in animal minds of Spanish primary school children. The study also considered the effects of a child's age, school year group, gender, and pet ownership on their beliefs in animal mind. The Child-BAM questionnaire, concerning the mental capabilities of eight different species (human, chimpanzee, dog, cow, otter, sparrow, frog, and fish), was distributed at a primary school sited in Cordoba, Spain. A total of 416 participants were included aged between 6 and 13 years. Each child provided scores for animals’ ability to have intelligence, experience pain, fear, happiness, and sadness, and total scores for the eight species were calculated. The results showed that children's beliefs about animal minds differed depending on the type of animal, and that children were more likely to believe in the emotional capacities of animals rather than their cognitive capabilities. Dogs achieved similar scores to humans regarding all capabilities, and higher than any other species, while the cow, fish, and frog generally scored the lowest. Age, school year group, and having a companion animal at home affected beliefs in animal minds, whereas gender had no effect. This study highlights cultural similarities in children's beliefs about animal minds and the potential importance of this variable for future research in child–animal interactions.

AB - Beliefs concerning the mental experiences of nonhuman animals have been related to how people treat, see, and take care of nonhuman animals. Whereas this issue has been the subject of several studies on adults, few have been conducted with children. Taking advantage of a recently published scale, the Child-BAM questionnaire, we aimed to explore the beliefs in animal minds of Spanish primary school children. The study also considered the effects of a child's age, school year group, gender, and pet ownership on their beliefs in animal mind. The Child-BAM questionnaire, concerning the mental capabilities of eight different species (human, chimpanzee, dog, cow, otter, sparrow, frog, and fish), was distributed at a primary school sited in Cordoba, Spain. A total of 416 participants were included aged between 6 and 13 years. Each child provided scores for animals’ ability to have intelligence, experience pain, fear, happiness, and sadness, and total scores for the eight species were calculated. The results showed that children's beliefs about animal minds differed depending on the type of animal, and that children were more likely to believe in the emotional capacities of animals rather than their cognitive capabilities. Dogs achieved similar scores to humans regarding all capabilities, and higher than any other species, while the cow, fish, and frog generally scored the lowest. Age, school year group, and having a companion animal at home affected beliefs in animal minds, whereas gender had no effect. This study highlights cultural similarities in children's beliefs about animal minds and the potential importance of this variable for future research in child–animal interactions.

KW - animals

KW - belief in animal mind

KW - Child-BAM

KW - children

KW - human-animal interaction

KW - sentience

KW - Spanish

U2 - 10.1080/08927936.2018.1505340

DO - 10.1080/08927936.2018.1505340

M3 - Article

VL - 31

SP - 599

EP - 614

JO - Anthrozoös

JF - Anthrozoös

SN - 0892-7936

IS - 5

ER -