A review of the positive impact of a self administered motivational instrument (SAMI) on deep and strategic approaches to study and on academic attainment

Tim Duffy, Russell Rimmer

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This research concerns the wider context of behaviour change and approaches to study among students in higher education. Drawing on the counselling approach known as motivational interviewing, a Self Administered Motivational Instrument (SAMI) has been designed in which students take decisions about changing their approaches to study. Motivational interviewing has been demonstrated to positively influence a range of behaviours, including alcohol- and drug
misuse and weight loss. The SAMI is paper-based and as the name suggests is self-administered.
Within the SAMI, students are asked to rate their academic performances if they continue to study as they are and if they change their study approaches. These questions were designed to stimulate ambivalence, if warranted, over current study approach. This is also engendered by asking students to complete the reliable, valid and relatively brief deep and strategic components of a shortened version of the RASI learning-style instrument (Duff, 1997). This shortened RASI is known as the DRASI.
The SAMI has been tested in a controlled study with 328 first, second and third year university students in Scotland, UK. In this paper the design of the SAMI and the controlled study are reported.
The main conclusions are:
When the SAMI is applied, approaches to study change. In particular, there was an onaverage increase in strategic approaches to learning. Further, greater strategic scores among those who completed the SAMI, were associated with a greater likelihood of attaining the top two grades of A or B1. Thus, in line with applications of brief motivational interventions in other areas, there is evidence of effectiveness.
• A small to moderate effect size of 0.32 was noted for strategic scores within the intervention group. Teachers, students and policy makers might regard this as a reasonable return for a low cost, easily administered intervention.
Further research is required to assess if similar outcomes occur when the SAMI is applied in different academic environments, with or without support from academic staff, over longer periods and using different media, such as electronic delivery
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)104-115
Number of pages12
JournalReflecting Education
Volume5
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 2009

Fingerprint

student
ambivalence
learning
student teacher
counseling
alcohol
electronics
staff
university
costs
performance
evidence
education
Group

Keywords

  • Approaches to study
  • Student motivation
  • Brief intervention

Cite this

@article{3e4b15a09ae14ab5bc87bdf371ea8bea,
title = "A review of the positive impact of a self administered motivational instrument (SAMI) on deep and strategic approaches to study and on academic attainment",
abstract = "This research concerns the wider context of behaviour change and approaches to study among students in higher education. Drawing on the counselling approach known as motivational interviewing, a Self Administered Motivational Instrument (SAMI) has been designed in which students take decisions about changing their approaches to study. Motivational interviewing has been demonstrated to positively influence a range of behaviours, including alcohol- and drugmisuse and weight loss. The SAMI is paper-based and as the name suggests is self-administered.Within the SAMI, students are asked to rate their academic performances if they continue to study as they are and if they change their study approaches. These questions were designed to stimulate ambivalence, if warranted, over current study approach. This is also engendered by asking students to complete the reliable, valid and relatively brief deep and strategic components of a shortened version of the RASI learning-style instrument (Duff, 1997). This shortened RASI is known as the DRASI.The SAMI has been tested in a controlled study with 328 first, second and third year university students in Scotland, UK. In this paper the design of the SAMI and the controlled study are reported.The main conclusions are: When the SAMI is applied, approaches to study change. In particular, there was an onaverage increase in strategic approaches to learning. Further, greater strategic scores among those who completed the SAMI, were associated with a greater likelihood of attaining the top two grades of A or B1. Thus, in line with applications of brief motivational interventions in other areas, there is evidence of effectiveness.• A small to moderate effect size of 0.32 was noted for strategic scores within the intervention group. Teachers, students and policy makers might regard this as a reasonable return for a low cost, easily administered intervention.Further research is required to assess if similar outcomes occur when the SAMI is applied in different academic environments, with or without support from academic staff, over longer periods and using different media, such as electronic delivery",
keywords = "Approaches to study, Student motivation, Brief intervention",
author = "Tim Duffy and Russell Rimmer",
year = "2009",
language = "English",
volume = "5",
pages = "104--115",
journal = "Reflecting Education",
issn = "1746-9082",
number = "2",

}

A review of the positive impact of a self administered motivational instrument (SAMI) on deep and strategic approaches to study and on academic attainment. / Duffy, Tim; Rimmer, Russell.

In: Reflecting Education, Vol. 5, No. 2, 2009, p. 104-115.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - A review of the positive impact of a self administered motivational instrument (SAMI) on deep and strategic approaches to study and on academic attainment

AU - Duffy, Tim

AU - Rimmer, Russell

PY - 2009

Y1 - 2009

N2 - This research concerns the wider context of behaviour change and approaches to study among students in higher education. Drawing on the counselling approach known as motivational interviewing, a Self Administered Motivational Instrument (SAMI) has been designed in which students take decisions about changing their approaches to study. Motivational interviewing has been demonstrated to positively influence a range of behaviours, including alcohol- and drugmisuse and weight loss. The SAMI is paper-based and as the name suggests is self-administered.Within the SAMI, students are asked to rate their academic performances if they continue to study as they are and if they change their study approaches. These questions were designed to stimulate ambivalence, if warranted, over current study approach. This is also engendered by asking students to complete the reliable, valid and relatively brief deep and strategic components of a shortened version of the RASI learning-style instrument (Duff, 1997). This shortened RASI is known as the DRASI.The SAMI has been tested in a controlled study with 328 first, second and third year university students in Scotland, UK. In this paper the design of the SAMI and the controlled study are reported.The main conclusions are: When the SAMI is applied, approaches to study change. In particular, there was an onaverage increase in strategic approaches to learning. Further, greater strategic scores among those who completed the SAMI, were associated with a greater likelihood of attaining the top two grades of A or B1. Thus, in line with applications of brief motivational interventions in other areas, there is evidence of effectiveness.• A small to moderate effect size of 0.32 was noted for strategic scores within the intervention group. Teachers, students and policy makers might regard this as a reasonable return for a low cost, easily administered intervention.Further research is required to assess if similar outcomes occur when the SAMI is applied in different academic environments, with or without support from academic staff, over longer periods and using different media, such as electronic delivery

AB - This research concerns the wider context of behaviour change and approaches to study among students in higher education. Drawing on the counselling approach known as motivational interviewing, a Self Administered Motivational Instrument (SAMI) has been designed in which students take decisions about changing their approaches to study. Motivational interviewing has been demonstrated to positively influence a range of behaviours, including alcohol- and drugmisuse and weight loss. The SAMI is paper-based and as the name suggests is self-administered.Within the SAMI, students are asked to rate their academic performances if they continue to study as they are and if they change their study approaches. These questions were designed to stimulate ambivalence, if warranted, over current study approach. This is also engendered by asking students to complete the reliable, valid and relatively brief deep and strategic components of a shortened version of the RASI learning-style instrument (Duff, 1997). This shortened RASI is known as the DRASI.The SAMI has been tested in a controlled study with 328 first, second and third year university students in Scotland, UK. In this paper the design of the SAMI and the controlled study are reported.The main conclusions are: When the SAMI is applied, approaches to study change. In particular, there was an onaverage increase in strategic approaches to learning. Further, greater strategic scores among those who completed the SAMI, were associated with a greater likelihood of attaining the top two grades of A or B1. Thus, in line with applications of brief motivational interventions in other areas, there is evidence of effectiveness.• A small to moderate effect size of 0.32 was noted for strategic scores within the intervention group. Teachers, students and policy makers might regard this as a reasonable return for a low cost, easily administered intervention.Further research is required to assess if similar outcomes occur when the SAMI is applied in different academic environments, with or without support from academic staff, over longer periods and using different media, such as electronic delivery

KW - Approaches to study

KW - Student motivation

KW - Brief intervention

M3 - Article

VL - 5

SP - 104

EP - 115

JO - Reflecting Education

JF - Reflecting Education

SN - 1746-9082

IS - 2

ER -